Arginine-binding RNAs resembling TAR identified by in vitro selection

Specific binding of the human immunodeficiency virus Tar protein to its RNA site (TAR) is mediated largely by a single arginine residue located within a basic region of the protein. Many essential features of the interaction can be mimicked by the free amino acid arginine, and an NMR model has been proposed in which the arginine guanidinium group binds to a guanine base in the major groove and to two phosphates adjacent to a bulge, with the RNA structure stabilized by a base triple between a U in the bulge and an adjacent A:U base pair. To compare the TAR structure to other arginine-binding RNAs, we performed in vitro selection experiments and identified RNAs with arginine-binding affinities similar to TAR. About 40% of the selected RNAs contained the same motif found in TAR: two stems separated by a bulge of at least two nucleotides, a U at the 5' position of the bulge, and G:C and A:U base pairs above the bulge. In many cases, the upper stems contained only the G:C and A:U pairs, located next to small loops. Chemical modification experiments demonstrated that these ''TAR-like'' RNAs bound arginine in a manner similar to TAR, and in some cases identified nucleotides outside the binding site that contributed to binding. To explore how small loops might help stabilize the structures of adjacent arginine-binding sites, we measured arginine-binding affinities of TAR-like RNAs having all possible three-nucleotide loops. An RNA with a UAG loop bound with highest affinity, and chemical modification and RNase mapping experiments suggested that the RNA changes conformation upon arginine binding, converting a large unstructured loop into a bulge conformation related to that of TAR. The results suggest that the arginine-binding site in TAR is structurally versatile and demonstrate how binding can be modulated by the surrounding RNA context.