The use of deciles of the citation impact to evaluate different fields of research in Israel

被引:10
作者
Czapski, G [1 ]
机构
[1] Hebrew Univ Jerusalem, Dept Phys Chem, IL-91904 Jerusalem, Israel
关键词
D O I
10.1007/BF02459291
中图分类号
TP39 [计算机的应用];
学科分类号
081203 ; 0835 ;
摘要
One often uses the average citation impact factor in order to perform international comparisons between the levels of scientific performance within given disciplines. In averaging over all (or all cited) papers one may give undue weight to papers with few citations while, in fact, the standing of a country within a given field would be better assessed by looking only at the "successful" papers in that discipline. The present papers suggests that one should do so by averaging citations only over the ten (or twenty) percent of the most cited papers in a discipline and use these in order to establish a ranking between countries. The case of Israel is used as an illustration of this approach.
引用
收藏
页码:437 / 443
页数:7
相关论文
共 11 条
[1]   WORLD SCIENCE IN THE EIGHTIES - NATIONAL PERFORMANCES IN PUBLICATION OUTPUT AND CITATION IMPACT, 1985-1989 VERSUS 1980-1984 .2. LIFE SCIENCES, ENGINEERING, AND MATHEMATICS [J].
BRAUN, T ;
GLANZEL, W ;
MACZELKA, H ;
SCHUBERT, A .
SCIENTOMETRICS, 1994, 31 (01) :3-30
[2]   WORLD SCIENCE IN THE EIGHTIES - NATIONAL PERFORMANCES IN PUBLICATION OUTPUT AND CITATION IMPACT, 1985-1989 VERSUS 1980-1984 .1. ALL SCIENCE FIELDS COMBINED, PHYSICS, AND CHEMISTRY [J].
BRAUN, T ;
GLANZEL, W ;
MACZELKA, H ;
SCHUBERT, A .
SCIENTOMETRICS, 1994, 29 (03) :299-334
[3]  
Braun T., 1985, SCIENTOMETRIC INDICA
[4]   DISCIPLINE IMPACT FACTORS - METHOD FOR DETERMINING CORE JOURNAL LISTS [J].
HIRST, G .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR INFORMATION SCIENCE, 1978, 29 (04) :171-172
[5]   INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS OF SCIENTIFIC PERFORMANCE REVISITED [J].
IRVINE, J ;
MARTIN, BR .
SCIENTOMETRICS, 1989, 15 (5-6) :369-392
[6]  
MARSHAKOVASHAIK.I, 1995, P 5 INT C INT SOC SC, P323
[7]   The standard impact factor as an evaluation tool of science fields and scientific journals [J].
MarshakovaShaikevich, I .
SCIENTOMETRICS, 1996, 35 (02) :283-290
[8]   SCIENTOMETRIC DATAFILES - A COMPREHENSIVE SET OF INDICATORS ON 2649 JOURNALS AND 96 COUNTRIES IN ALL MAJOR SCIENCE FIELDS AND SUBFIELDS 1981-1985 [J].
SCHUBERT, A ;
GLANZEL, W ;
BRAUN, T .
SCIENTOMETRICS, 1989, 16 (1-6) :3-&
[9]  
Schubert A., 1988, HDB QUANTITATIVE STU, P137, DOI 10.1016/B978-0-444-70537-2.50010-6
[10]   Measuring the impact of scientific publications. The case of the biomedical sciences [J].
Schwartz, S ;
Hellin, JL .
SCIENTOMETRICS, 1996, 35 (01) :119-132