Evidence-based guidelines on the therapeutic use of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS): An update (2014-2018)

被引：1973

作者：

Lefaucheur, Jean-Pascal ^{[1
,2
]}

Aleman, Andre ^{[3
]}

Baeken, Chris ^{[4
,5
,6
]}

Benninger, David H. ^{[7
]}

Brunelin, Jerome ^{[8
,9
]}

Di Lazzaro, Vincenzo ^{[10
]}

Filipovic, Sasa R. ^{[11
]}

Grefkes, Christian ^{[12
,13
]}

Hasan, Alkomiet ^{[14
]}

Hummel, Friedhelm C. ^{[15
,16
,17
,18
,19
]}

Jaaskelainen, Satu K. ^{[20
,21
]}

Langguth, Berthold ^{[22
]}

Leocani, Letizia ^{[23
,24
]}

Londero, Alain ^{[25
]}

Nardone, Raffaele ^{[26
,27
,28
]}

Nguyen, Jean-Paul ^{[29
,30
]}

Nyffeler, Thomas ^{[31
,32
,33
]}

Oliveira-Maia, Albino J. ^{[34
,35
,36
]}

Oliviero, Antonio ^{[37
]}

Padberg, Frank ^{[14
]}

Palm, Ulrich ^{[14
,38
]}

Paulus, Walter ^{[39
]}

Poulet, Emmanuel ^{[8
,9
,40
]}

Quartarone, Angelo ^{[41
]}

Rachid, Fady

Rektorova, Irena ^{[42
,43
,44
]}

Rossi, Simone ^{[45
]}

Sahlsten, Hanna ^{[21
,46
]}

Schecklmann, Martin ^{[22
]}

Szekely, David ^{[47
]}

Ziemann, Ulf ^{[48
,49
]}

机构：

[1] Paris Est Creteil Univ, Fac Med, EA4391, ENT Team, Creteil, France

[2] Henri Mondor Hosp, AP HP, Dept Physiol, Clin Neurophysiol Unit, Creteil, France

[3] Univ Groningen, Univ Med Ctr Groningen, Dept Biomed Sci Cells & Syst, Groningen, Netherlands

[4] Univ Ghent, Dept Psychiat & Med Psychol, Ghent Expt Psychiat GHEP Lab, Ghent, Belgium

[5] Univ Hosp UZBrussel, Dept Psychiat, Brussels, Belgium

[6] Eindhoven Univ Technol, Dept Elect Engn, Eindhoven, Netherlands

[7] CHU Vaudois, Neurol Serv, Dept Clin Neurosci, Lausanne, Switzerland

[8] Lyon 1 Univ, Ctr Hosp Le Vinatier, Ctr Neurosci Res Lyon, PsyR2 Team,U1028,INSERM, Bron, France

[9] Lyon 1 Univ, Ctr Hosp Le Vinatier, Ctr Neurosci Res Lyon, UMR5292,CNRS, Bron, France

[10] Univ Campus Biomed Roma, Dept Med, Unit Neurol Neurophysiol Neurobiol, Rome, Italy

[11] Univ Belgrade, Inst Med Res, Dept Human Neurosci, Belgrade, Serbia

[12] Cologne Univ Hosp, Dept Neurol, Cologne, Germany

[13] Julich Res Ctr, Inst Neurosci & Med INM3, Julich, Germany

[14] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, Univ Hosp, Dept Psychiat & Psychotherapy, Munich, Germany

[15] EPFL, Swiss Fed Inst Technol, Defitech Chair Clin Neuroengn, Ctr Neuroprosthet CNP, Geneva, Switzerland

[16] EPFL, Swiss Fed Inst Technol, Brain Mind Inst, Geneva, Switzerland

[17] Swiss Fed Inst Technol, EPFL, Defitech Chair Clin Neuroengn, Valais, Switzerland

[18] Clin Romande Readaptat, Sion, Switzerland

[19] Univ Geneva, Clin Neurosci, Med Sch, Geneva, Switzerland

[20] Turku Univ Hosp, Dept Clin Neurophysiol, Turku, Finland

[21] Univ Turku, Turku, Finland

[22] Univ Regensburg, Dept Psychiat & Psychotherapy, Regensburg, Germany

[23] Univ Vita Salute San Raffaele, IRCCS San Raffaele, Inst Expt Neurol INSPE, Dept Neurorehabil, Milan, Italy

[24] Univ Vita Salute San Raffaele, IRCCS San Raffaele, Inst Expt Neurol INSPE, Expt Neurophysiol Unit, Milan, Italy

[25] Univ Paris 05, Sorbonne Paris Cite, Hop Europeen Georges Pompidou, Dept Otorhinolaryngol Head & Neck Surg, Paris, France

[26] Franz Tappeiner Hosp, Dept Neurol, Merano, Italy

[27] Paracelsus Med Univ, Christian Doppler Med Ctr, Dept Neurol, Salzburg, Austria

[28] Karl Landsteiner Inst Neurorehabil & Raumfahrtneu, Salzburg, Austria

[29] ELSAN, Clin Breteche, Multidisciplinary Pain Ctr, Nantes, France

[30] CHU Nord Laennec, Univ Hosp, UIC22 CAT2 EA3826, Multidisciplinary Pain Palliat & Support Care Ctr, Nantes, France

[31] Univ Bern, ARTORG Ctr Biomed Engn Res, Gerontechnol & Rehabil Grp, Bern, Switzerland

[32] Univ Bern, Dept Neurol, Percept & Eye Movement Lab, Bern, Switzerland

[33] Luzerner Kantonsspital, Neuroctr, Luzern, Switzerland

[34] Champalimaud Ctr Unknown, Champalimaud Res & Clin Ctr, Lisbon, Portugal

[35] Ctr Hosp Lisboa Ocidental, Dept Psychiat & Mental Hlth, Lisbon, Portugal

[36] Univ Nova Lisboa, Fac Ciencias Med, NOVA Med Sch, Lisbon, Portugal

[37] Hosp Nacl Paraplej, SESCAM, FENNSI Grp, Toledo, Spain

[38] Med Pk Chiemseeblick, Bernau, Germany

[39] Univ Med Ctr Gottingen, Dept Clin Neurophysiol, Gottingen, Germany

[40] Hosp Civils Lyon, Grp Hosp Ctr, Edouard Herriot Hosp, Dept Emergency Psychiat, Lyon, France

[41] Univ Messina, Dept Biomed Dent Sci & Morphol & Funct Images, Messina, Italy

[42] Masaryk Univ, Cent European Inst Technol, CEITEC MU, Appl Neurosci Res Grp, Brno, Czech Republic

[43] Masaryk Univ, St Annes Univ Hosp, Dept Neurol 1, Brno, Czech Republic

[44] Masaryk Univ, Fac Med, Brno, Czech Republic

[45] Univ Siena, Neurol & Clin Neurophysiol Unit, Si BIN Lab Human Physiol Sect, Dept Med Surg & Neurosci, Siena, Italy

[46] Mehilainen, ENT Clin, Turku, Finland

[47] Princess Grace Hosp, Dept Psychiat, Monaco, Monaco

[48] Eberhard Karls Univ Tubingen, Dept Neurol & Stroke, Tubingen, Germany

[49] Eberhard Karls Univ Tubingen, Hertie Inst Clin Brain Res, Tubingen, Germany

来源：

CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY | 2020年 / 131卷 / 02期

关键词：

Cortex; Indication; Neurology; Neuromodulation; Noninvasive brain stimulation; Psychiatry; Treatment; THETA-BURST STIMULATION; DORSOLATERAL PREFRONTAL CORTEX; OBSESSIVE-COMPULSIVE DISORDER; NONINVASIVE BRAIN-STIMULATION; SHAM-CONTROLLED-TRIAL; HIGH-FREQUENCY RTMS; MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDER; TREATMENT-RESISTANT DEPRESSION; PREDOMINANT NEGATIVE SYMPTOMS; AUDITORY VERBAL HALLUCINATIONS;

D O I：

10.1016/j.clinph.2019.11.002

中图分类号：

R74 [神经病学与精神病学];

学科分类号：

100204 [神经病学];

摘要：

A group of European experts reappraised the guidelines on the therapeutic efficacy of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) previously published in 2014 [Lefaucheur et al., Clin Neurophysiol 2014;125:2150-206]. These updated recommendations take into account all rTMS publications, including data prior to 2014, as well as currently reviewed literature until the end of 2018. Level A evidence (definite efficacy) was reached for: high-frequency (HF) rTMS of the primary motor cortex (M1) contralateral to the painful side for neuropathic pain; HF-rTMS of the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) using a figure-of-8 or a Hl-coil for depression; low-frequency (LF) rTMS of contralesional M1 for hand motor recovery in the post-acute stage of stroke. Level B evidence (probable efficacy) was reached for: HF-rTMS of the left M1 or DLPFC for improving quality of life or pain, respectively, in fibromyalgia; HF-rTMS of bilateral M1 regions or the left DLPFC for improving motor impairment or depression, respectively, in Parkinson's disease; HF-rTMS of ipsilesional M1 for promoting motor recovery at the post-acute stage of stroke; intermittent theta burst stimulation targeted to the leg motor cortex for lower limb spasticity in multiple sclerosis; HF-rTMS of the right DLPFC in posttraumatic stress disorder; LF-rTMS of the right inferior frontal gyrus in chronic post-stroke non-fluent aphasia; LF-rTMS of the right DLPFC in depression; and bihemispheric stimulation of the DLPFC combining right-sided LF-rTMS (or continuous theta burst stimulation) and left-sided HF-rTMS (or intermittent theta burst stimulation) in depression. Level A/B evidence is not reached concerning efficacy of rTMS in any other condition. The current recommendations are based on the differences reached in therapeutic efficacy of real vs. sham rTMS protocols, replicated in a sufficient number of independent studies. This does not mean that the benefit produced by rTMS inevitably reaches a level of clinical relevance. (C) 2019 International Federation of Clinical Neurophysiology. Published by Elsevier B.V.

引用

页码：474 / 528

页数：55

共 564 条

[1]

Intermittent theta-burst transcranial magnetic stimulation for autism spectrum disorder: an open-label pilot study [J].

Abujadi, Caio ;

Croarkin, Paul E. ;

Bellini, Bianca B. ;

Brentani, Helena ;

Marcolin, Marco A. .

REVISTA BRASILEIRA DE PSIQUIATRIA, 2018, 40 (03) :309-311

[2]

Primed Physical Therapy Enhances Recovery of Upper Limb Function in Chronic Stroke Patients [J].

Ackerley, Suzanne J. ;

Byblow, Winston D. ;

Barber, P. Alan ;

MacDonald, Hayley ;

McIntyre-Robinson, Andrew ;

Stinear, Cathy M. .

NEUROREHABILITATION AND NEURAL REPAIR, 2016, 30 (04) :339-348

[3]

Deep Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation of the Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex in Alcohol Use Disorder Patients: Effects on Dopamine Transporter Availability and Alcohol Intake [J].

Addolorato, Giovanni ;

Antonelli, Mariangela ;

Cocciolillo, Fabrizio ;

Vassallo, Gabriele A. ;

Tarli, Claudia ;

Sestito, Luisa ;

Mirijello, Antonio ;

Ferrulli, Anna ;

Pizzuto, Daniele A. ;

Camardese, Giovanni ;

Miceli, Antonio ;

Diana, Marco ;

Giordano, Alessandro ;

Gasbarrini, Antonio ;

Di Giuda, Daniela .

EUROPEAN NEUROPSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY, 2017, 27 (05) :450-461

[4]

Comparison of "standard" and "navigated" procedures of TMS coil positioning over motor, premotor and prefrontal targets in patients with chronic pain and depression [J].

Ahdab, R. ;

Ayache, S. S. ;

Brugieres, P. ;

Goujon, C. ;

Lefaucheur, J. -P. .

NEUROPHYSIOLOGIE CLINIQUE-CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY, 2010, 40 (01) :27-36

[5]

The Hand Motor Hotspot is not Always Located in the Hand Knob: A Neuronavigated Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Study [J].

Ahdab, Rechdi ;

Ayache, Samar S. ;

Brugieres, Pierre ;

Farhat, Wassim H. ;

Lefaucheur, Jean-Pascal .

BRAIN TOPOGRAPHY, 2016, 29 (04) :590-597

[6]

Unilateral right and bilateral dorsolateral prefrontal cortex transcranial magnetic stimulation in treatment post-traumatic stress disorder: A randomized controlled study [J].

Ahmadizadeh, Mohammad-Javad ;

Rezaei, Mehdi .

BRAIN RESEARCH BULLETIN, 2018, 140 :334-340

[7]

Alcala-Lozano, R. ;

Morelos-Santana, E. ;

Cortes-Sotres, J. F. ;

Garza-Villarreal, E. A. ;

Sosa-Ortiz, A. L. ;

Gonzalez-Olvera, J. J. .

BRAIN STIMULATION, 2018, 11 (03) :625-627

[8]

Overlap of large-scale brain networks may explain the similar cognitive improvement of single-site vs multi-site rTMS in Alzheimer's disease [J].

Alcala-Lozano, Ruth ;

Garza-Villarreal, Eduardo A. .

BRAIN STIMULATION, 2018, 11 (04) :942-944

[9]

Moderate effects of noninvasive brain stimulation of the frontal cortex for improving negative symptoms in schizophrenia: Meta-analysis of controlled trials [J].

Aleman, Andre ;

Enriquez-Geppert, Stefanie ;

Knegtering, Henderikus ;

Dlabac-de Lange, Jozarni J. .

NEUROSCIENCE AND BIOBEHAVIORAL REVIEWS, 2018, 89 :111-118

[10]

Right prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in obsessive-compulsive disorder:: A double-blind, placebo-controlled study [J].

Alonso, P ;

Pujol, J ;

Cardoner, N ;

Benlloch, L ;

Deus, J ;

Menchón, JM ;

Capdevila, A ;

Vallejo, J .

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 2001, 158 (07) :1143-1145

← 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 →