Mechanism of cytotoxicity of catechols and a naphthalenediol in PC12-AC cells: the connection between extracellular autoxidation and molecular electronic structure

ortho-Hydroxyphenols (catechols) form a common structural unit in naturally occurring antioxidants such as polyphenols. They also show pro-oxidant characteristics, which depend on their particular structure. Here we examined the acetylated versions of three catechols and a naphthalenediol for cytotoxicity to adrenal PC12-AC cells. We found that the three catechols H1 (a p-methoxycatechol), H2 (a catechol analog of alpha-tocopherol), and H4 (a dioxymethylene-substituted catechol) strongly upregulate glutathione (GSH) in 24 h, whereas 1,4-dipropyl-2,3-naphthalenediol (DPND) does not. Upregulation of GSH is primarily caused by oxidative stress in the form of hydrogen peroxide generation, and both GSH upregulation and the rate of H2O2 generation correlate well with the cytotoxicity. The major source of H2O2 is autoxidation in the extracellular space, which results from transport of the (deacetylated) hydroquinone form outside the cell, rather than internal redox cycling. DPND is much less cytotoxic than any of the catechols. We show that this is because it cannot form a naphthoquinone due to the energy penalty associated with the loss of aromaticity in the benzene ring adjacent to the diol functional group. The relevance of these results to the design of antioxidants is discussed. (C) 2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.