A test for concordance between the multilocus genealogies of genes and microsatellites in the pathogenic fungus Coccidioides immitis

Uncovering the correct phylogeny of closely related species requires analysis of multiple gene genealogies or, alternatively, genealogies inferred from the multiple alleles found at highly polymorphic loci, such as microsatellites. However, a concern in using microsatellites is that constraints on allele sizes may occur, resulting in homoplasious distributions of alleles, leading to incorrect phylogenies. Seven microsatellites from the pathogenic fungus Coccidioides immitis were sequenced for 20 clinical isolates chosen to represent the known genetic diversity of the pathogen. An organismal phylogeny for C. immitis was inferred from microsatellite-flanking sequence polymorphisms and other restriction fragment length polymorphism-containing loci. Two microsatellite genetic distances were then used to determine phylogenies for C. immitis, and the trees found by these three methods were compared. Congruence between the organismal and microsatellite phylogenies occurred when microsatellite distances were based on simple allele frequency data. However, complex mutation events at some loci made distances based on stepwise mutation models unreliable. Estimates of times of divergence for the two species of C. immitis based on microsatellites were significantly lower than those calculated from flanking sequence, most likely due to constraints on microsatellite allele sizes. Flanking-sequence insertions/deletions significantly decreased the accuracy of genealogical information inferred from microsatellite loci and caused interspecific length homoplasies at one of the seven loci. Our analysis shows that microsatellites are useful phylogenetic markers, although care should be taken to choose loci with appropriate flanking sequences when they are intended for use in evolutionary studies.