Are Himalayan Sherpas better protected against brain damage associated with extreme altitude climbs?

被引:31
作者
Garrido, E
Segura, R
Capdevila, A
Pujol, J
Javierre, C
Ventura, JL
机构
[1] CTR HIGH PERFORMANCE & EXERCISE PHYSIOL, BARCELONA, SPAIN
[2] MAGNET RESONANCE CTR PEDRALBES, BARCELONA, SPAIN
[3] UNIV BARCELONA, PRINCEPS ESPANYA HOSP, E-08007 BARCELONA, SPAIN
[4] UNIV BARCELONA, SCH MED, DEPT PHYSIOL SCI & NUTR, E-08007 BARCELONA, SPAIN
关键词
altitude; brain; climbing; hypoxia; magnetic resonance; neurological symptoms; Sherpas;
D O I
10.1042/cs0900081
中图分类号
R-3 [医学研究方法]; R3 [基础医学];
学科分类号
1001 ;
摘要
1. The potential risk of brain damage when lowlanders attempt to climb the highest summits is a well-known fact, However, very little is known about what occurs to Himalayan natives, perfectly adapted to high altitude, when performing the same type of activity. 2. Taking into account their long-life climbing experience at extreme altitudes, we examined seven of the most recognized Sherpas with the aim of performing a comprehensive neurological evaluation based on medical history, physical examination and magnetic resonance brain imaging, We compared them with one group of 21 lowland elite climbers who had ascended to altitudes of over 8000 m, and another control group of 21 healthy individuals who had never been exposed to high altitude. 3. While all of the lowland climbers presented psychoneurological symptoms during or after the expeditions, and 13 of them (61%) showed magnetic resonance abnormalities (signs of mild cortical atrophy and/or periventricular high-intensity signal areas in the white matter), only one Sherpa (14%) showed similar changes in the scans, presenting neurological symptoms at extreme altitude, The neurological examination was normal in all three groups, and no neuroimaging abnormalities were detected in the control group. 4. The significant differences, in both clinical and neuroimaging terms, suggest that Sherpa highlanders have better brain protection when exposed to extreme altitude, Although the key to protection against cerebral hypoxia cannot be established, it is possible that an increase in the usually short period of acclimatization could minimize brain damage in those lowlanders who attempt the highest summits without supplementary oxygen.
引用
收藏
页码:81 / 85
页数:5
相关论文
共 23 条
[1]   OPERATION EVEREST II - ARTERIAL OXYGEN-SATURATION AND SLEEP AT EXTREME SIMULATED ALTITUDE [J].
ANHOLM, JD ;
POWLES, ACP ;
DOWNEY, R ;
HOUSTON, CS ;
SUTTON, JR ;
BONNET, MH ;
CYMERMAN, A .
AMERICAN REVIEW OF RESPIRATORY DISEASE, 1992, 145 (04) :817-826
[2]   THE BILINGUAL CONSULTATION [J].
EBDEN, P ;
BHATT, A ;
CAREY, OJ ;
HARRISON, B .
LANCET, 1988, 1 (8581) :347-347
[3]   CORTICAL ATROPHY AND OTHER BRAIN MAGNETIC-RESONANCE-IMAGING (MRI) CHANGES AFTER EXTREMELY HIGH-ALTITUDE CLIMBS WITHOUT OXYGEN [J].
GARRIDO, E ;
CASTELLO, A ;
VENTURA, JL ;
CAPDEVILA, A ;
RODRIGUEZ, FA .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 1993, 14 (04) :232-234
[4]   NEW EVIDENCE FROM MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING OF BRAIN CHANGES AFTER CLIMBS AT EXTREME ALTITUDE [J].
GARRIDO, E ;
SEGURA, R ;
CAPDEVILA, A ;
ALDOMA, J ;
RODRIGUEZ, FA ;
JAVIERRE, C ;
VENTURA, JLI .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSIOLOGY AND OCCUPATIONAL PHYSIOLOGY, 1995, 70 (06) :477-481
[5]   LEUKOARAIOSIS [J].
HACHINSKI, VC ;
POTTER, P ;
MERSKEY, H .
ARCHIVES OF NEUROLOGY, 1987, 44 (01) :21-23
[6]  
HARVEY TC, 1988, LANCET, V2, P639
[7]   THE BRAIN AT HIGH-ALTITUDE - HYPOMETABOLISM AS A DEFENSE AGAINST CHRONIC HYPOXIA [J].
HOCHACHKA, PW ;
CLARK, CM ;
BROWN, WD ;
STANLEY, C ;
STONE, CK ;
NICKLES, RJ ;
ZHU, GG ;
ALIEN, PS ;
HOLDEN, JE .
JOURNAL OF CEREBRAL BLOOD FLOW AND METABOLISM, 1994, 14 (04) :671-679
[8]   THE COST TO THE CENTRAL NERVOUS-SYSTEM OF CLIMBING TO EXTREMELY HIGH-ALTITUDE [J].
HORNBEIN, TF ;
TOWNES, BD ;
SCHOENE, RB ;
SUTTON, JR ;
HOUSTON, CS .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1989, 321 (25) :1714-1719
[9]   LEUKO-ARAIOSIS ON MAGNETIC-RESONANCE-IMAGING AND SPEED OF MENTAL PROCESSING [J].
JUNQUE, C ;
PUJOL, J ;
VENDRELL, P ;
BRUNA, O ;
JODAR, M ;
RIBAS, JC ;
VINAS, J ;
CAPDEVILA, A ;
MARTIVILALTA, JL .
ARCHIVES OF NEUROLOGY, 1990, 47 (02) :151-156
[10]   ACID-BASE IN SHERPA ALTITUDE RESIDENTS AND LOWLANDERS AT 4880 M [J].
LAHIRI, S ;
MILLEDGE, JS .
RESPIRATION PHYSIOLOGY, 1967, 2 (03) :323-&