Fallacies in the pathological confirmation of the diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease

被引:108
作者
Bowler, JV
Munoz, DG
Merskey, H
Hachinski, V
机构
[1] Charing Cross & Westminster Med Sch, Dept Clin Neurosci, Memory Clin, London W6 8RF, England
[2] Univ Western Ontario, John P Robarts Res Inst, London, ON, Canada
关键词
Alzheimer's disease; necropsy; diagnostic accuracy; verification bias;
D O I
10.1136/jnnp.64.1.18
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Objective-Necropsy confirmed clinical diagnostic accuracy for Alzheimer's disease is claimed to exceed 90%. This figure contains two fallacies; it includes cases in which Alzheimer's disease exists with other diseases affecting cognition and the studies that report these figures excluded cases without necropsy (verification bias). The effect of these errors is estimated. Methods-Data were taken from the University of Western Ontario Dementia Study, a registry of dementia cases with clinical and psychometric follow up to necropsy based in a university memory disorders clinic with secondary and tertiary referrals. Data were available on 307 patients; 200 (65%) had clinically diagnosed Alzheimer's disease, 12 (4%) vascular dementia, 47 (15%) mixed dementia, and 48 (16%) had other diagnoses. One hundred and ninety two of 307 cases (63%) died and 122 of 192 fatalities (64%) had necropsies. The pathological material was interpreted in two ways, allowing and disallowing coexistent disease in making a diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease. In cases without necropsy, progressive cognitive loss was used as a marker for degenerative dementia. The outcome measures of interest were the positive predictive value of a clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease allowing and disallowing coexistent diseases and with and without correction for cases that were not necropsied. Results-The clinical diagnoses differed significantly between the population who died and those who did not. In cases without necropsy, 22% had no dementia on follow up, concentrated in early cases and men, showing considerable scope for verification bias. The positive predictive value of a diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease was 81% including coexistent diseases, falling to 44% when limited to pure cases. Combined, these factors reduce the positive predictive value to 38% for pure Alzheimer's disease. Conclusions-Correction for dual pathology and verification bias halves the positive predictive value of the clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease. Data derived from necropsy studies cannot be extrapolated to the whole population. This has important implications including uncertainty about diagnosis and prognosis and a dilution effect in therapeutic trials in Alzheimer's disease.
引用
收藏
页码:18 / 24
页数:7
相关论文
共 43 条
  • [1] DO NONSTEROIDAL ANTIINFLAMMATORY DRUGS DECREASE THE RISK FOR ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE - THE ROTTERDAM STUDY
    ANDERSEN, K
    LAUNER, LJ
    OTT, A
    HOES, AW
    BRETELER, MMB
    HOFMAN, A
    [J]. NEUROLOGY, 1995, 45 (08) : 1441 - 1445
  • [2] [Anonymous], 1980, DSM 3
  • [3] THE NATURAL-HISTORY OF ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE - DESCRIPTION OF STUDY COHORT AND ACCURACY OF DIAGNOSIS
    BECKER, JT
    BOLLER, F
    LOPEZ, OL
    SAXTON, J
    MCGONIGLE, KL
    MOOSSY, J
    HANIN, I
    WOLFSON, SK
    DETRE, K
    HOLLAND, A
    GUR, D
    LATCHAW, R
    BRENNER, R
    [J]. ARCHIVES OF NEUROLOGY, 1994, 51 (06) : 585 - 594
  • [4] ASSESSMENT OF DIAGNOSTIC-TESTS WHEN DISEASE VERIFICATION IS SUBJECT TO SELECTION BIAS
    BEGG, CB
    GREENES, RA
    [J]. BIOMETRICS, 1983, 39 (01) : 207 - 215
  • [5] Comparative evolution of Alzheimer disease, vascular dementia, and mixed dementia
    Bowler, JV
    Eliasziw, M
    Steenhuis, R
    Munoz, DG
    Fry, R
    Merskey, H
    Hachinski, VC
    [J]. ARCHIVES OF NEUROLOGY, 1997, 54 (06) : 697 - 703
  • [6] INVERSE ASSOCIATION OF ANTIINFLAMMATORY TREATMENTS AND ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE - INITIAL RESULTS OF A COTWIN CONTROL STUDY
    BREITNER, JCS
    GAU, BA
    WELSH, KA
    PLASSMAN, BL
    MCDONALD, WM
    HELMS, MJ
    ANTHONY, JC
    [J]. NEUROLOGY, 1994, 44 (02) : 227 - 232
  • [7] COGNITIVE DYSFUNCTION FOLLOWING SUBCORTICAL INFARCTION
    CORBETT, A
    BENNETT, H
    KOS, S
    [J]. ARCHIVES OF NEUROLOGY, 1994, 51 (10) : 999 - 1007
  • [8] VASCULAR DEMENTIA - A CLINICOPATHOLOGICAL STUDY
    DELSER, T
    BERMEJO, F
    PORTERA, A
    ARREDONDO, JM
    BOURAS, C
    CONSTANTINIDIS, J
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE NEUROLOGICAL SCIENCES, 1990, 96 (01) : 1 - 17
  • [9] Temporal pattern of cognitive decline and incontinence is different in Alzheimer's disease and diffuse Lewy body disease
    DelSer, T
    Munoz, DG
    Hachinski, V
    [J]. NEUROLOGY, 1996, 46 (03) : 682 - 686
  • [10] ACCURACY OF THE CLINICAL-DIAGNOSIS OF VASCULAR DEMENTIA - A PROSPECTIVE CLINICAL AND POST-MORTEM NEUROPATHOLOGICAL STUDY
    ERKINJUNTTI, T
    HALTIA, M
    PALO, J
    SULKAVA, R
    PAETAU, A
    [J]. JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 1988, 51 (08) : 1037 - 1044