Craniofacial ontogeny in centrosaurine dinosaurs (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae):: taxonomic and behavioral implications

Centrosaurine ceratopsians are characterized by well developed nasal horncores or bosses, relatively abbreviated supraorbital horncores or bosses, and adorned parietosquamosal frills. Recent study of several paucispecific (low diversity) bonebed assemblages in Alberta and Montana has contributed greatly to our understanding of ontogenetic and taxonomic variation in the skulls of centrosaurines. Relative age determination of centrosaurines is now possible through examination of ontogenetic change ill several characters, including the surface bone morphology of specific skeletal elements. The within-group taxonomy of centrosauriues, is based almost entirely on characters of the skull roof relating particularly to horns and frills. Juvenile and sub-adult centrosaurines are characterized by relatively simple? unadorned skulls compared to their adult counterparts. As in numerous living taxa, the cranial ornaments of centrosaurines developed late in ontogeny, as individuals approached or attained adult size. An important implication arising directly from this study is that juvenile and sub-adult centrosaurines are difficult to distinguish taxonomically at the specific level. Two monospecific genera represented only by immature materials, Brachyceratops montanensis and Monoclonius crassus cannot be defended and should be considered nomina dubia. The late ontogenetic development and diverse taxonomic variation of horn and frill morphologies support the contention that these structures are best interpreted as reproductive characters employed in mate competition. (C) 1997 The Linnean Society of London.