Argon behaviour in gem-quality orthoclase from Madagascar: Experiments and some consequences for 40Ar/39Ar geochronology

被引:45
作者
Arnaud, NO
Kelley, SP
机构
[1] UNIV CLERMONT FERRAND, CLERMONT FERRAND, FRANCE
[2] OPEN UNIV, DEPT EARTH SCI, MILTON KEYNES MK7 6AA, BUCKS, ENGLAND
关键词
D O I
10.1016/S0016-7037(97)00152-X
中图分类号
P3 [地球物理学]; P59 [地球化学];
学科分类号
0708 ; 070902 ;
摘要
In order to investigate argon diffusion in as simple a K-feldspar structure as possible, a single crystal of the gem-quality Itrongay K-feldspar from Madagascar has been studied using cycled step heating, ultra-violet (UV) laser depth profiling, in vacuo crushing, Electron Microprobe Analysis (EMPA) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques. The results have been modelled using both the multidomain model and a multipath model invoking pipe or short circuit (SC) diffusion. Cycle heating (both forward and reversed) indicates a very retentive K-feldspar, in which the gnat majority of argon release conforms to a simple model of volume diffusion with a single domain size, a single activation energy, and is associated with a plateau age of 435 +/- 8 Ma. However, the first 1% of argon release exhibits younger ages and the same type of complex behaviour seen in other K-feldspars. Modelling the argon release in terms of multidomains yields good fits to data with four domains of varying activation energies. An alternative model for the argon release, involving not only volume diffusion through the lattice but also SC or pipe diffusion and mass transfer between lattice and rapid diffusion paths, provides a good though less sophisticated model to explain the argon release. Argon concentration/depth profiles of a previously outgassed sample, measured using the UV laser ablation technique, exhibited argon loss in only the upper 5-10 mu m. Argon loss calculated from the measured profiles suggests that the low temperature domains outgassed during step heating were within 5-10 mu m of the grain surfaces and thus may be artefacts of sample preparation and surface texture effects. In vacuo crushing of an untreated sample released argon with an older age than the plateau value, which was not detected by any of the other analytical techniques. However, previously cycled step heated samples contained very little excess argon, suggesting the existence of traps within the feldspar structure into which 40Ar diffused in nature to yield apparent excess argon, but which were then filled with corresponding 39Ar during cycle heating. The K-feldspar structure illuminated by these studies is one in which argon diffuses through the lattice over distances of at least 100 mu m probably via a volume diffusion mechanism to the grain boundaries. However, close to the surface argon may also diffuse along fast diffusion paths resulting from natural traps opened during sample preparation. Though restricted to very small volumes of gas in the case of the Itrongay orthoclase gem, the existence of the traps has potentially important consequences for 40Ar/39Ar geochronology applied to K-feldspars. Copyright (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd. In order to investigate argon diffusion in as simple a K-feldspar structure as possible, a single crystal of the gem-quality Itrongay K-feldspar from Madagascar has been studied using cycled step heating, ultra-violet (UV) laser depth profiling, in vacuo crushing, Electron Microprobe Analysis (EMPA) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques. The results have been modelled using both the multidomain model and a multipath model invoking pipe or short circuit (SC) diffusion. Cycle heating (both forward and reversed) indicates a very retentive K-feldspar, in which the gnat majority of argon release conforms to a simple model of volume diffusion with a single domain size, a single activation energy, and is associated with a plateau age of 435 +/- 8 Ma. However, the first 1% of argon release exhibits younger ages and the same type of complex behaviour seen in other K-feldspars. Modelling the argon release in terms of multidomains yields good fits to data with four domains of varying activation energies. An alternative model for the argon release, involving not only volume diffusion through the lattice but also SC or pipe diffusion and mass transfer between lattice and rapid diffusion paths, provides a good though less sophisticated model to explain the argon release. Argon concentration/depth profiles of a previously outgassed sample, measured using the UV laser ablation technique, exhibited argon loss in only the upper 5-10 mu m. Argon loss calculated from the measured profiles suggests that the low temperature domains outgassed during step heating were within 5-10 mu m of the grain surfaces and thus may be artefacts of sample preparation and surface texture effects. In vacuo crushing of an untreated sample released argon with an older age than the plateau value, which was not detected by any of the other analytical techniques. However, previously cycled step heated samples contained very little excess argon, suggesting the existence of traps within the feldspar structure into which 40Ar diffused in nature to yield apparent excess argon, but which were then filled with corresponding 39Ar during cycle heating. The K-feldspar structure illuminated by these studies is one in which argon diffuses through the lattice over distances of at least 100 mu m probably via a volume diffusion mechanism to the grain boundaries. However, close to the surface argon may also diffuse along fast diffusion paths resulting from natural traps opened during sample preparation. Though restricted to very small volumes of gas in the case of the Itrongay orthoclase gem, the existence of the traps has potentially important consequences for 40Ar/39Ar geochronology applied to K-feldspars. Copyright (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd. In order to investigate argon diffusion in as simple a K-feldspar structure as possible, a single crystal of the gem-quality Itrongay K-feldspar from Madagascar has been studied using cycled step heating, ultra-violet (UV) laser depth profiling, in vacuo crushing, Electron Microprobe Analysis (EMPA) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques. The results have been modelled using both the multidomain model and a multipath model invoking pipe or short circuit (SC) diffusion. Cycle heating (both forward and reversed) indicates a very retentive K-feldspar, in which the gnat majority of argon release conforms to a simple model of volume diffusion with a single domain size, a single activation energy, and is associated with a plateau age of 435 +/- 8 Ma. However, the first 1% of argon release exhibits younger ages and the same type of complex behaviour seen in other K-feldspars. Modelling the argon release in terms of multidomains yields good fits to data with four domains of varying activation energies. An alternative model for the argon release, involving not only volume diffusion through the lattice but also SC or pipe diffusion and mass transfer between lattice and rapid diffusion paths, provides a good though less sophisticated model to explain the argon release. Argon concentration/depth profiles of a previously outgassed sample, measured using the UV laser ablation technique, exhibited argon loss in only the upper 5-10 mu m. Argon loss calculated from the measured profiles suggests that the low temperature domains outgassed during step heating were within 5-10 mu m of the grain surfaces and thus may be artefacts of sample preparation and surface texture effects. In vacuo crushing of an untreated sample released argon with an older age than the plateau value, which was not detected by any of the other analytical techniques. However, previously cycled step heated samples contained very little excess argon, suggesting the existence of traps within the feldspar structure into which 40Ar diffused in nature to yield apparent excess argon, but which were then filled with corresponding 39Ar during cycle heating. The K-feldspar structure illuminated by these studies is one in which argon diffuses through the lattice over distances of at least 100 mu m probably via a volume diffusion mechanism to the grain boundaries. However, close to the surface argon may also diffuse along fast diffusion paths resulting from natural traps opened during sample preparation. Though restricted to very small volumes of gas in the case of the Itrongay orthoclase gem, the existence of the traps has potentially important consequences for 40Ar/39Ar geochronology applied to K-feldspars. Copyright (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd. In order to investigate argon diffusion in as simple a K-feldspar structure as possible, a single crystal of the gem-quality Itrongay K-feldspar from Madagascar has been studied using cycled step heating, ultra-violet (UV) laser depth profiling, in vacuo crushing, Electron Microprobe Analysis (EMPA) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques. The results have been modelled using both the multidomain model and a multipath model invoking pipe or short circuit (SC) diffusion. Cycle heating (both forward and reversed) indicates a very retentive K-feldspar, in which the gnat majority of argon release conforms to a simple model of volume diffusion with a single domain size, a single activation energy, and is associated with a plateau age of 435 +/- 8 Ma. However, the first 1% of argon release exhibits younger ages and the same type of complex behaviour seen in other K-feldspars. Modelling the argon release in terms of multidomains yields good fits to data with four domains of varying activation energies. An alternative model for the argon release, involving not only volume diffusion through the lattice but also SC or pipe diffusion and mass transfer between lattice and rapid diffusion paths, provides a good though less sophisticated model to explain the argon release. Argon concentration/depth profiles of a previously outgassed sample, measured using the UV laser ablation technique, exhibited argon loss in only the upper 5-10 mu m. Argon loss calculated from the measured profiles suggests that the low temperature domains outgassed during step heating were within 5-10 mu m of the grain surfaces and thus may be artefacts of sample preparation and surface texture effects. In vacuo crushing of an untreated sample released argon with an older age than the plateau value, which was not detected by any of the other analytical techniques. However, previously cycled step heated samples contained very little excess argon, suggesting the existence of traps within the feldspar structure into which 40Ar diffused in nature to yield apparent excess argon, but which were then filled with corresponding 39Ar during cycle heating. The K-feldspar structure illuminated by these studies is one in which argon diffuses through the lattice over distances of at least 100 mu m probably via a volume diffusion mechanism to the grain boundaries. However, close to the surface argon may also diffuse along fast diffusion paths resulting from natural traps opened during sample preparation. Though restricted to very small volumes of gas in the case of the Itrongay orthoclase gem, the existence of the traps has potentially important consequences for 40Ar/39Ar geochronology applied to K-feldspars. Copyright (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd. In order to investigate argon diffusion in as simple a K-feldspar structure as possible, a single crystal of the gem-quality Itrongay K-feldspar from Madagascar has been studied using cycled step heating, ultra-violet (UV) laser depth profiling, in vacuo crushing, Electron Microprobe Analysis (EMPA) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques. The results have been modelled using both the multidomain model and a multipath model invoking pipe or short circuit (SC) diffusion. Cycle heating (both forward and reversed) indicates a very retentive K-feldspar, in which the gnat majority of argon release conforms to a simple model of volume diffusion with a single domain size, a single activation energy, and is associated with a plateau age of 435 +/- 8 Ma. However, the first 1% of argon release exhibits younger ages and the same type of complex behaviour seen in other K-feldspars. Modelling the argon release in terms of multidomains yields good fits to data with four domains of varying activation energies. An alternative model for the argon release, involving not only volume diffusion through the lattice but also SC or pipe diffusion and mass transfer between lattice and rapid diffusion paths, provides a good though less sophisticated model to explain the argon release. Argon concentration/depth profiles of a previously outgassed sample, measured using the UV laser ablation technique, exhibited argon loss in only the upper 5-10 mu m. Argon loss calculated from the measured profiles suggests that the low temperature domains outgassed during step heating were within 5-10 mu m of the grain surfaces and thus may be artefacts of sample preparation and surface texture effects. In vacuo crushing of an untreated sample released argon with an older age than the plateau value, which was not detected by any of the other analytical techniques. However, previously cycled step heated samples contained very little excess argon, suggesting the existence of traps within the feldspar structure into which 40Ar diffused in nature to yield apparent excess argon, but which were then filled with corresponding 39Ar during cycle heating. The K-feldspar structure illuminated by these studies is one in which argon diffuses through the lattice over distances of at least 100 mu m probably via a volume diffusion mechanism to the grain boundaries. However, close to the surface argon may also diffuse along fast diffusion paths resulting from natural traps opened during sample preparation. Though restricted to very small volumes of gas in the case of the Itrongay orthoclase gem, the existence of the traps has potentially important consequences for 40Ar/39Ar geochronology applied to K-feldspars. Copyright (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd.
引用
收藏
页码:3227 / 3255
页数:29
相关论文
共 36 条
[1]   HIGH COOLING AND DENUDATION RATES AT KONGUR-SHAN, EASTERN PAMIR (XINJIANG, CHINA) REVEALED BY 40AR/39AR ALKALI FELDSPAR THERMOCHRONOLOGY [J].
ARNAUD, NO ;
BRUNEL, M ;
CANTAGREL, JM ;
TAPPONNIER, P .
TECTONICS, 1993, 12 (06) :1335-1346
[2]   STRONTIUM DIFFUSION KINETICS IN AMPHIBOLES AND SIGNIFICANCE TO THERMAL HISTORY DETERMINATIONS [J].
BRABANDER, DJ ;
GILETTI, BJ .
GEOCHIMICA ET COSMOCHIMICA ACTA, 1995, 59 (11) :2223-2238
[3]   40AR-39AR ANALYSIS OF PERTHITE MICROTEXTURES AND FLUID INCLUSIONS IN ALKALI FELDSPARS FROM THE KLOKKEN SYENITE, SOUTH GREENLAND [J].
BURGESS, R ;
KELLEY, SP ;
PARSONS, I ;
WALKER, FDL ;
WORDEN, RH .
EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS, 1992, 109 (1-2) :147-167
[4]  
Carroll D.S., 1994, Noble Gas Geochemistry and Cosmochemistry, P325
[5]  
COOMBS DS, 1952, MINERAL MAG, V226, P409
[6]  
Crank J., 1975, The Mathematics of Diffusion, V2nd ed.
[7]  
DICKINSON JT, 1992, PHYS CHEM MINER, V18, P453
[8]   CLOSURE TEMPERATURE IN COOLING GEOCHRONOLOGICAL AND PETROLOGICAL SYSTEMS [J].
DODSON, MH .
CONTRIBUTIONS TO MINERALOGY AND PETROLOGY, 1973, 40 (03) :259-274
[9]   AR-40 DIFFUSION IN HOMOGENEOUS ORTHOCLASE AND AN INTERPRETATION OF AR DIFFUSION IN K-FELDSPARS [J].
FOLAND, KA .
GEOCHIMICA ET COSMOCHIMICA ACTA, 1974, 38 (01) :151-166
[10]  
FOLAND KA, 1994, NATO ADV SCI INST SE, V421, P415