This study investigated the effects of estrogens on sexual differentiation in sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax L.), a gonochoristic marine teleost that under culture conditions has a histologically sexual undifferentiated period that covers most of the first year of life, after which most individuals develop as males. Sea bass that had no noticeable histological sign of sex differentiation were fed estrogens at two doses (5 or 10 mg kg(-1) food) and for different periods ranging from 48 to 426 days post fertilization (DPF). Exposure to the synthetic estrogen 17 alpha-ethynylestradiol (EE2) at 10 mg kg(-1) food from 60 to 260 DPF, including the sensitive period to equivalent doses of synthetic androgens previously determined for this species (126-226 DPF), significantly (p < 0.05) more than doubled the number of juvenile females to 80%, compared to the control value of 33%, and completely suppressed gonadal development in the remaining 20% of the population. This suggests that the period during which sea bass gonads exhibit high sensitivity to androgens is also very sensitive to estrogens. A comparable exposure to the natural estrogen estradiol-17 beta (E-2) resulted in 13% of the fish having suppressed gonadal development, but induced 57% of the fish to develop gonads with germinal tissue of both sexes, suggesting a pivotal role for E? during this sensitive period. Earlier exposure to EE2 at 10 mg kg(-1) food from 48-88 DPF, significantly (p < 0.05) increased the number of females to 62% from 36% in the control group, allowing for the normal testicular development in the remaining fish. In contrast, a later chronic exposure (226-426 DPF) to E-2 at either 5 or 10 mg kg(-1) food, starting when the gonads showed no sign of sexual differentiation but past the critical sensitive period, had no effect on the resulting overall sex ratios, indicating that after this period responsiveness of the gonads to estrogens decreases as gonadal sexual differentiation progresses. However, the consequences of this apparently innocuous exposure were later manifested in adults, exemplified by a significant dose-dependent reduction in the number of mature males at 626 DPF, coinciding with the second reproductive season, the time when males normally reach sexual maturation in cultured sea bass. This suggests that chronic exposure to E-2 past the critical sensitive period may not affect the sex ratio, but could result in alterations in the male reproductive organs. This was later verified by histological analysis which revealed a significant (p < 0.05) dose-dependent reduction of the surface of the testicular lobules in the remaining males that did not mature. Together, these experiments illustrate both readily observable and subtle effects of estrogens on sex proportions, gonadal morphology and maturation rates, providing evidence that estrogen exposure can have delayed action in a teleost in a manner similar to the effects described for mammalian species. The possible existence of effects of this latter type in adult fish could be considered when evaluating the consequences of deliberate or accidental exposure to estrogens or putative estrogenic chemicals, particularly if such exposure had taken place during sex differentiation.
