INTERPRETIVE BIOETHICS - THE WAY OF DISCERNMENT

This paper critically appraises the applied action-guide approach to bioethics and finds it wanting in two ways: it is tethered to a social contract view of the doctor-patient relationship that is largely incompatible with experiences of illness and care; and, as a formalist doctrine, it lacks critical edge and tends toward accommodationism. An alternative approach is recommended that involves interpreting moral experience by means once associated with the rhetorical arts - practical reasoning, hermeneutics, casuistry, and thick description. © 1990 Kluwer Academic Publishers.