CORRELATION OF CARCINOGENIC POTENCY WITH MOUSE-SKIN P-32 POSTLABELING AND MUTA-RMOUSE LAC Z- MUTATION DATA FOR DMBA AND ITS K-REGION SULFUR ISOSTERE - COMPARISON WITH ACTIVITIES OBSERVED IN STANDARD GENOTOXICITY ASSAYS

The genotoxicities in vitro and in vivo of the mouse-skin carcinogen 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene (DMBA) have been compared with those of its weakly carcinogenic 4,5-sulphur analogue, 6,11-dimethyl-benzo[b]naphtho-[2,3-d]thiophene (S-DMBA). The only datasets that correlated with the relative carcinogenicity of these agents to the skin were those conducted using topically exposed mouse skin. Thus, both chemicals induced lacZ- mutations in the skin of lacZ+ transgenic mice, and both produced DNA adducts on mouse-skin DNA as assessed using the P-32-postlabeling technique. In each case, DMBA gave a stronger response than did S-DMBA. In contrast to these responses, only DMBA was active in the mouse bone-marrow micronucleus assay and in the C3H10T1/2 in vitro cell transformation assay. Both chemicals were mutagenic to Salmonella and of approximately equal potency. The molecular geometry of DMBA and S-DMBA are compared, and divergent CASE predictions of activity in the Salmonella assay and skin-painting bioassay are discussed. The importance of conducting predictive genotoxicity assays in systems close to those in which carcinogenicity is to be assessed is emphasized by these data.