ANALYSIS OF MIN-NORM AND MUSIC WITH ARBITRARY ARRAY GEOMETRY

被引:57
作者
FU, L
VACCARO, RJ
机构
[1] Dep't. of Electrical Engineering, University of Rhode Island, Kingston
关键词
D O I
10.1109/7.62249
中图分类号
V [航空、航天];
学科分类号
08 ; 0825 ;
摘要
A new, nonasymptotic performance comparison between the Min-Norm and MUSIC algorithms is presented for estimating the directions of arrival of narrowband plane waves impinging on an array of sensors. The analysis is based on a finite amount of sensor data, unlike many previous asymptotic analyses. The analysis presented here makes the assumption of high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and it applies to arrays of arbitrary geometry. It is shown that Min-Norm can be expressed as a certain data-dependent weighted MUSIC algorithm, and this relationship allows a unified performance comparison. It is also shown that the variances of the estimated directions-of-arrival from the MUSIC algorithm are always smaller than those of the Min-Norm algorithm at high SNR when both algorithms employ a numerical search procedure to obtain the estimates. © 1990 IEEE
引用
收藏
页码:976 / 985
页数:10
相关论文
共 35 条
[1]  
BARABELL AJ, 1983, 1983 P IEEE INT C AC, V1, P336
[2]  
BIENVENU G, 1980, 1980 P IEEE INT C AC, P307
[3]  
BURG JP, 1975, THESIS STANFORD U ST
[4]   HIGH-RESOLUTION FREQUENCY-WAVENUMBER SPECTRUM ANALYSIS [J].
CAPON, J .
PROCEEDINGS OF THE IEEE, 1969, 57 (08) :1408-&
[5]   THEORETICAL PERFORMANCE PREDICTION OF THE MUSIC ALGORITHM [J].
FARRIER, DR ;
JEFFRIES, DJ ;
MARDANI, R .
IEE PROCEEDINGS-F RADAR AND SIGNAL PROCESSING, 1988, 135 (03) :216-224
[6]  
FARRIER DR, 1988, 1877 P IEEE INT C AC, P2873
[7]   PERTURBATION ANALYSIS OF TK METHOD FOR HARMONIC RETRIEVAL PROBLEMS [J].
HUA, YB ;
SARKAR, TK .
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ACOUSTICS SPEECH AND SIGNAL PROCESSING, 1988, 36 (02) :228-240
[8]   ASYMPTOTIC RESULTS FOR EIGENVECTOR METHODS [J].
JEFFRIES, DJ ;
FARRIER, DR .
IEE PROCEEDINGS-F RADAR AND SIGNAL PROCESSING, 1985, 132 (07) :589-594
[9]   THE APPLICATION OF SPECTRAL ESTIMATION METHODS TO BEARING ESTIMATION PROBLEMS [J].
JOHNSON, DH .
PROCEEDINGS OF THE IEEE, 1982, 70 (09) :1018-1028
[10]   THE STATISTICAL PERFORMANCE OF THE MUSIC AND THE MINIMUM-NORM ALGORITHMS IN RESOLVING PLANE-WAVES IN NOISE [J].
KAVEH, M ;
BARABELL, AJ .
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ACOUSTICS SPEECH AND SIGNAL PROCESSING, 1986, 34 (02) :331-341