ESTIMATING EXPOSURE EFFECTS BY MODELING THE EXPECTATION OF EXPOSURE CONDITIONAL ON CONFOUNDERS

被引:244
作者
ROBINS, JM [1 ]
MARK, SD [1 ]
NEWEY, WK [1 ]
机构
[1] MIT,DEPT ECON,CAMBRIDGE,MA 02139
关键词
CAUSAL INFERENCE; COVARIANCE ADJUSTMENT; EPIDEMIOLOGIC METHODS; PROPENSITY SCORE; SEMIPARAMETRIC EFFICIENCY; SEMIPARAMETRIC REGRESSION;
D O I
10.2307/2532304
中图分类号
Q [生物科学];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
In order to estimate the causal effects of one or more exposures or treatments on an outcome of interest, one has to account for the effect of "confounding factors" which both covary with the exposures or treatments and are independent predictors of the outcome. In this paper we present regression methods which, in contrast to standard methods, adjust for the confounding effect of multiple continuous or discrete covariates by modelling the conditional expectation of the exposures or treatments given the confounders. In the special case of a univariate dichotomous exposure or treatment, this conditional expectation is identical to what Rosenbaum and Rubin have called the propensity score. They have also proposed methods to estimate causal effects by modelling the propensity score. Our methods generalize those of Rosenbaum and Rubin in several ways. First, our approach straightforwardly allows for multivariate exposures or treatments, each of which may be continuous, ordinal, or discrete. Second, even in the case of a single dichotomous exposure, our approach does not require subclassification or matching on the propensity score so that the potential for "residual confounding," i.e., bias, due to incomplete matching is avoided. Third, our approach allows a rather general formalization of the idea that it is better to use the "estimated propensity score" than the true propensity score even when the true score is known. The additional power of our approach derives from the fact that we assume the causal effects of the exposures or treatments can be described by the parametric component of a semiparametric regression model. To illustrate our methods, we reanalyze the effect of current cigarette smoking on the level of forced expiratory volume in one second in a cohort of 2,713 adult white males. We compare the results with those obtained using standard methods.
引用
收藏
页码:479 / 495
页数:17
相关论文
共 30 条
[1]   INFORMATION AND ASYMPTOTIC EFFICIENCY IN PARAMETRIC NONPARAMETRIC MODELS [J].
BEGUN, JM ;
HALL, WJ ;
HUANG, WM ;
WELLNER, JA .
ANNALS OF STATISTICS, 1983, 11 (02) :432-452
[2]  
BICKEL PJ, 1992, EFFICIENT ADAPTIVE I
[3]   ASYMPTOTIC EFFICIENCY IN ESTIMATION WITH CONDITIONAL MOMENT RESTRICTIONS [J].
CHAMBERLAIN, G .
JOURNAL OF ECONOMETRICS, 1987, 34 (03) :305-334
[4]  
Cox D.R., 1974, THEORETICAL STAT
[5]   CUMULATIVE AND REVERSIBLE EFFECTS OF LIFETIME SMOKING ON SIMPLE TESTS OF LUNG-FUNCTION IN ADULTS [J].
DOCKERY, DW ;
SPEIZER, FE ;
FERRIS, BG ;
WARE, JH ;
LOUIS, TA ;
SPIRO, A .
AMERICAN REVIEW OF RESPIRATORY DISEASE, 1988, 137 (02) :286-292
[6]  
EFRON B, 1978, BIOMETRIKA, V65, P657
[7]  
GAIL MH, 1984, BIOMETRIKA, V71, P431
[8]  
Huber PJ., 1981, ROBUST STATISTICS
[9]   GRAPHICAL METHODS FOR ASSESSING LOGISTIC-REGRESSION MODELS [J].
LANDWEHR, JM ;
PREGIBON, D ;
SHOEMAKER, AC .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN STATISTICAL ASSOCIATION, 1984, 79 (385) :61-71
[10]   LONGITUDINAL DATA-ANALYSIS USING GENERALIZED LINEAR-MODELS [J].
LIANG, KY ;
ZEGER, SL .
BIOMETRIKA, 1986, 73 (01) :13-22