THE EFFECT OF GROUP-INTERACTION PROCESSES ON PERFORMANCE IN TIME-SERIES EXTRAPOLATION

被引:18
作者
ANG, S
OCONNOR, M
机构
[1] UNIV MINNESOTA,CARLSON SCH MANAGEMENT,MINNEAPOLIS,MN 55455
[2] UNIV NEW S WALES,SCH INFORMAT SYST,KENSINGTON,NSW 2033,AUSTRALIA
关键词
GROUP JUDGMENT; FORECAST ACCURACY;
D O I
10.1016/0169-2070(91)90048-Z
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
This study explores the ability of groups to forecast and establish judgmental confidence intervals in time series extrapolation. Thirty-six three-person groups were used to evaluate four different group interaction processes. In addition to staticized, nominal group technique and consensus processes, the study utilizes a modified consensus process, where a selected group member completes the task prior to group discussion and interaction. Using real life time series, subjects produced forecasts and related confidence intervals for six periods. Groups in the modified-consensus structuring process exhibited significantly greater forecast accuracy than all other experimental conditions (p < 0.001). The superiority was most pronounced for series of high forecast difficulty. These results are discussed in relation to the contribution of the initial estimates as an anchor on which the modified-consensus group can focus. © 1991.
引用
收藏
页码:141 / 149
页数:9
相关论文
共 36 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], 1985, LONG RANGE FORECASTI
[2]   GROUP CONFIDENCE PRESSURES IN ITERATIVE DECISIONS [J].
BOJE, DM ;
MURNIGHAN, JK .
MANAGEMENT SCIENCE, 1982, 28 (10) :1187-1196
[3]  
*C BOARD, 1978, SAL FOR
[4]   EVALUATION OF EXTRAPOLATIVE FORECASTING METHODS - RESULTS OF A SURVEY OF ACADEMICIANS AND PRACTITIONERS [J].
CARBONE, R ;
ARMSTRONG, JS .
JOURNAL OF FORECASTING, 1982, 1 (02) :215-217
[5]  
CHALOS P, 1985, J APPL PSYCHOL, V10, P634
[6]  
EDMUNDSON RH, 1988, J FORECASTING, V7, P201
[7]   QUALITY OF GROUP JUDGMENT [J].
EINHORN, HJ ;
HOGARTH, RM ;
KLEMPNER, E .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1977, 84 (01) :158-172
[8]  
Ferrell W.R., 1985, BEHAV DECISION MAKIN, P111
[9]   WHEN ORACLES FAIL - A COMPARISON OF 4 PROCEDURES FOR AGGREGATING SUBJECTIVE-PROBABILITY FORECASTS [J].
FISCHER, GW .
ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR AND HUMAN PERFORMANCE, 1981, 28 (01) :96-110
[10]  
Golembiewski R. T., 1962, SMALL GROUP ANAL RES