THE SURFACE BRIGHTNESS TEST FOR THE EXPANSION OF THE UNIVERSE .3. REDUCTION OF DATA FOR THE SEVERAL BRIGHTEST GALAXIES IN CLUSTERS TO STANDARD CONDITIONS AND A 1ST INDICATION THAT THE EXPANSION IS REAL

被引:55
作者
SANDAGE, A
PERELMUTER, JM
机构
[1] JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV, H ROWLAND DEPT PHYS & ASTRON, BALTIMORE, MD 21218 USA
[2] SPACE TELESCOPE SCI INST, BALTIMORE, MD 21218 USA
关键词
COSMOLOGY; GALAXIES; CLUSTERING; PHOTOMETRY;
D O I
10.1086/169832
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
Petrosian radii, effective radii, apparent magnitudes, and average surface brightnesses are obtained for the first few ranked galaxies in 56 nearby clusters and groups using data from the literature. The radii of first-ranked galaxies continue to increase faster than Hubble's constant surface brightness scaling law of M approximately -5 log R, steepening the variation of <SB> with M calibrated in Paper II. The strong correlation of <SB> with M (and consequently with R) makes the correction of <SB> data to "standard conditions" for the first few ranked cluster galaxies even more important than discussed in Paper II in a search for the Tolman SB effect to test the reality of the expansion. A Scott-like selection bias is present in the data we have used, causing the first-ranked galaxies in our sample to have brighter absolute magnitudes at larger redshifts. This creates an artificial correlation of <SB> with log (1 + z) that imitates the Tolman cosmological surface brightness dimming with redshift but with a 4 times larger amplitude than is expected from theory if the universe expands. The correlation is shown to be an artifact of the selection biases in the sample. It is demonstrated that biases of this kind can always be removed by reducing the <SB> values to a "standard condition" of either fixed M or fixed R by using the correlations calibrated here. We apply these reduction procedures to data on distant clusters obtained by Djorgovski and Spinrad and show that a strong Tolman-like signal is present that matches the required slope of <SB>/d log (1 + z) approximately 10 for an expanding manifold. Reasons are given to be cautious of the result despite its importance in justifying the standard model of cosmology by proving that the expansion is real. The conclusion from the present result, if confirmed, is that the conventional interpretation of the redshifts as a change of the cosmological metric scale factor with time is correct.
引用
收藏
页码:455 / 473
页数:19
相关论文
共 65 条
[1]  
Abell G. O., 1958, ASTROPHYS J SUPPL S, V3, P211
[2]  
[Anonymous], 1953, MON NOT R ASTRON SOC, V113, P658
[3]  
ARIMOTO N, 1989, EVOLUTIONARY PHENOMENA IN GALAXIES, P323
[4]   SPECTRAL EVOLUTION OF GALAXIES .1. EARLY-TYPE SYSTEMS [J].
BRUZUAL, G .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1983, 273 (01) :105-127
[5]   COLORS AND MAGNITUDES PREDICTED FOR HIGH REDSHIFT GALAXIES [J].
COLEMAN, GD ;
WU, CC ;
WEEDMAN, DW .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL SUPPLEMENT SERIES, 1980, 43 (03) :393-416
[6]   TOWARD THE APPLICATION OF A METRIC SIZE FUNCTION IN GALACTIC EVOLUTION AND COSMOLOGY [J].
DJORGOVSKI, S ;
SPINRAD, H .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1981, 251 (02) :417-423
[7]  
DJORGOVSKI S, 1985, LECT NOTES PHYS, V232, P193
[8]   SYSTEMATICS OF THE 4000 ANGSTROM BREAK IN THE SPECTRA OF GALAXIES [J].
DRESSLER, A ;
SHECTMAN, SA .
ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL, 1987, 94 (04) :899-905
[9]   SPECTROSCOPY OF GALAXIES IN DISTANT CLUSTERS .2. THE POPULATION OF THE 3C-295 CLUSTER [J].
DRESSLER, A ;
GUNN, JE .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1983, 270 (01) :7-19
[10]   SPECTROSCOPY OF GALAXIES IN DISTANT CLUSTERS .1. 1ST RESULTS FOR 3C-295 AND 0024+1654 [J].
DRESSLER, A ;
GUNN, JE .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1982, 263 (02) :533-545