REAL AND IMAGINED CLINICOPATHOLOGICAL LIMITS OF PRION DEMENTIA

The term ''prion dementia'' has been proposed to replace ''spongiform encephalopathy'', to accommodate the existence of atypical forms of these ''prion protein'' (PrP) cerebral amyloidoses that may not show spongiform changes in the brain. We tested brain tissue extracts for the presence of PrP from 46 cases (including 13 familial cases) of non-spongiform dementias with a variety of associated neurological signs, referred to our laboratory for primate transmission studies. None of the cases transmitted disease to primates, and none had PrP detectable by western immunoblots of extracted brain tissue. We conclude that prion dementias are not lurking undetected within the larger landscape of neurodegenerative disorders, and that their clinicopathological limits are, except for a small number of previously reported familial cases, essentially those of spongiform encephalopathy.