DO THE POOR SUE MORE - A CASE-CONTROL STUDY OF MALPRACTICE CLAIMS AND SOCIOECONOMIC-STATUS

被引:125
作者
BURSTIN, HR
JOHNSON, WG
LIPSITZ, SR
BRENNAN, TA
机构
[1] HARVARD UNIV,SCH PUBL HLTH,DEPT HLTH POLICY & MANAGEMENT,677 HUNTINGTON AVE,BOSTON,MA 02115
[2] BRIGHAM & WOMENS HOSP,DIV GEN MED,BOSTON,MA 02115
[3] HARVARD UNIV,SCH MED,BOSTON,MA 02115
[4] HARVARD UNIV,SCH PUBL HLTH,DEPT BIOSTAT,BOSTON,MA 02115
[5] ARIZONA STATE UNIV,SCH HLTH ADM & POLICY,TEMPE,AZ 85287
来源
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION | 1993年 / 270卷 / 14期
关键词
D O I
10.1001/jama.270.14.1697
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective.-To evaluate whether socioeconomic status is associated with risk of malpractice claims, particularly among those who have suffered medical injury. Design.-Case-control study. Setting.-Fifty-one hospitals in New York State. Methods.-The presence and severity of medical injury, defined as disability at the time of discharge or prolongation of the hospitalization caused by medical treatment as opposed to the disease process, were assessed through review of approximately 31 000 hospital records in New York in 1984. These sampled records were then linked to formal malpractice claims. To estimate the risk of malpractice claims by age, gender, race, insurance status, and income, we conducted a case-control study of claimant cases matched with nonclaimant controls. The cases were all those patients who filed malpractice claims referring to alleged malpractice during a sampled hospitalization. Physician reviewers had previously judged the level of disability that resulted from the medical injury. Claimants (n=51) were each matched with five nonclaimant controls on the basis of injury. Noninjured cases were matched with noninjured controls and injured cases were matched with injured controls. Results.-We found that poor patients (odds ratio [OR], 0.2; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.03 to 0.8) and uninsured patients (OR, 0.1; 95% CI, 0.005 to 0.9) were significantly less likely to file malpractice claims, after controlling for the severity of medical injury. Among patients who suffered medical injury, the elderly (OR, 0.2; 95% CI, 0.03. to 0.9) were also less likely to file claims. Gender and race were not independently associated with risk of malpractice claims. Conclusions.-Poor and uninsured patients are significantly less likely to sue for malpractice, even after controlling for the presence of medical injury. Fear of malpractice risk should not be a significant factor in the decision to serve the poor. Tort reforms that would protect physicians who serve the medically indigent from malpractice suits may not be warranted.
引用
收藏
页码:1697 / 1701
页数:5
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]  
BOUFFORD JI, 1986, COMMUNITY ORIENTED P
[2]   INCIDENCE OF ADVERSE EVENTS AND NEGLIGENCE IN HOSPITALIZED-PATIENTS - RESULTS OF THE HARVARD MEDICAL-PRACTICE STUDY-I [J].
BRENNAN, TA ;
LEAPE, LL ;
LAIRD, NM ;
HEBERT, L ;
LOCALIO, AR ;
LAWTHERS, AG ;
NEWHOUSE, JP ;
WEILER, PC ;
HIATT, HH .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1991, 324 (06) :370-376
[3]  
BRENNAN TA, 1992, YALE L POLY REV, V10, P431
[4]  
Breslow N, 1980, STATISTICAL METHODS, V32
[5]   SOCIOECONOMIC-STATUS AND RISK FOR SUBSTANDARD MEDICAL-CARE [J].
BURSTIN, HR ;
LIPSITZ, SR ;
BRENNAN, TA .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1992, 268 (17) :2383-2387
[6]  
BURSTIN HR, 1993, EC ANAL MED MALPRACT
[7]  
HUGHES D, 1989, MED PROFESSIONAL LIA, V2, P59
[8]  
LEWISIDEMA D, 1988, INCREASING PROVIDER
[9]   RELATION BETWEEN MALPRACTICE CLAIMS AND ADVERSE EVENTS DUE TO NEGLIGENCE - RESULTS OF THE HARVARD MEDICAL-PRACTICE STUDY-III [J].
LOCALIO, AR ;
LAWTHERS, AG ;
BRENNAN, TA ;
LAIRD, NM ;
HEBERT, LE ;
PETERSON, LM ;
NEWHOUSE, JP ;
WEILER, PC ;
HIATT, HH .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1991, 325 (04) :245-251
[10]   MEDICAL MALPRACTICE CLAIMS FILED BY MEDICAID AND NON-MEDICAID RECIPIENTS IN MARYLAND [J].
MUSSMAN, MG ;
ZAWISTOWICH, L ;
WEISMAN, CS ;
MALITZ, FE ;
MORLOCK, LL .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1991, 265 (22) :2992-2994