10-YEAR RESULTS OF A COMPARISON OF CONSERVATION WITH MASTECTOMY IN THE TREATMENT OF STAGE-I AND STAGE-II BREAST-CANCER

被引:653
作者
JACOBSON, JA
DANFORTH, DN
COWAN, KH
DANGELO, T
STEINBERG, SM
PIERCE, L
LIPPMAN, ME
LICHTER, AS
GLATSTEIN, E
OKUNIEFF, P
机构
[1] NCI,DIV CANC TREATMENT,CLIN ONCOL PROGRAM,SURG BRANCH,BETHESDA,MD 20892
[2] NCI,DIV CANC TREATMENT,CLIN ONCOL PROGRAM,MED BRANCH,BETHESDA,MD 20892
[3] NCI,DIV CANC TREATMENT,CLIN ONCOL PROGRAM,BIOSTAT & DATA MANAGEMENT SECT,BETHESDA,MD 20892
[4] NCI,DIV CANC TREATMENT,CLIN ONCOL PROGRAM,CANC NURSING SERV,BETHESDA,MD 20892
[5] UNIV MICHIGAN,MED CTR,DEPT RADIAT ONCOL,ANN ARBOR,MI 48109
[6] GEORGETOWN UNIV HOSP,LOMBARDI CANC CTR,WASHINGTON,DC 20007
[7] UNIV TEXAS,SW MED CTR,SIMMONS CANC CTR,DEPT RADIAT ONCOL,DALLAS,TX
关键词
D O I
10.1056/NEJM199504063321402
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background. Breast-conservation therapy for early-stage breast cancer is now an accepted treatment, but there is still controversy about its comparability with mastectomy. Between 1979 and 1987, the National Cancer Institute conducted a randomized, single-institution trial comparing lumpectomy, axillary dissection, and radiation with mastectomy and axillary dissection for stage I and II breast cancer, We update the results of that trial after a median potential follow-up of 10.1 years. Methods. Two hundred forty-seven patients with clinical stage I and II breast cancer were randomly assigned to undergo either modified radical mastectomy or lumpectomy, axillary dissection, and radiation therapy, The 237 patients who actually underwent randomization have been followed for a median of 10.1 years, The primary points were overall survival and disease-free survival. Results. At 10 years overall survival was 75 percent for the patients assigned to mastectomy and 77 percent for those assigned to lumpectomy plus radiation (P=0.89). Disease-free survival at 10 years was 69 percent for the patients assigned to mastectomy and 72 percent for those assigned to lumpectomy plus radiation (P=0.93). The rate of local regional recurrence at 10 years was 10 percent after mastectomy and 5 percent after lumpectomy plus radiation (P=0.17) after recurrences successfully treated by mastectomy were censored from the analysis. Conclusions, In the management of stage I and II breast cancer, breast conservation with lumpectomy and radiation offers results at 10 years that are equivalent to those with mastectomy.
引用
收藏
页码:907 / 911
页数:5
相关论文
共 24 条
[1]   PROGNOSIS FOLLOWING SALVAGE MASTECTOMY FOR RECURRENCE IN THE BREAST AFTER CONSERVATIVE SURGERY AND RADIATION-THERAPY FOR EARLY-STAGE BREAST-CANCER [J].
ABNER, AL ;
RECHT, A ;
EBERLEIN, T ;
COME, S ;
SHULMAN, L ;
HAYES, D ;
CONNOLLY, JL ;
SCHNITT, SJ ;
SILVER, B ;
HARRIS, JR .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 1993, 11 (01) :44-48
[2]   SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT IN THE BREAST-CANCER TRIALS [J].
ANGELL, M ;
KASSIRER, JP .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1994, 330 (20) :1448-1450
[3]  
Blichert-Toft M, 1992, J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr, P19
[4]   EARLY BREAST-CANCER - PREDICTORS OF BREAST RECURRENCE FOR PATIENTS TREATED WITH CONSERVATIVE SURGERY AND RADIATION-THERAPY [J].
BOYAGES, J ;
RECHT, A ;
CONNOLLY, JL ;
SCHNITT, SJ ;
GELMAN, R ;
KOOY, H ;
LOVE, S ;
OSTEEN, RT ;
CADY, B ;
SILVER, B ;
HARRIS, JR .
RADIOTHERAPY AND ONCOLOGY, 1990, 19 (01) :29-41
[5]   PROGNOSTIC-SIGNIFICANCE OF BREAST RELAPSE AFTER CONSERVATIVE TREATMENT IN NODE-NEGATIVE EARLY BREAST-CANCER [J].
CHAUVET, B ;
REYNAUDBOUGNOUX, A ;
CALAIS, G ;
PANEL, N ;
LANSAC, J ;
BOUGNOUX, P ;
LEFLOCH, O .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RADIATION ONCOLOGY BIOLOGY PHYSICS, 1990, 19 (05) :1125-1130
[6]   COMPLETE AXILLARY LYMPH-NODE DISSECTION FOR STAGE-I-II CARCINOMA OF THE BREAST [J].
DANFORTH, DN ;
FINDLAY, PA ;
MCDONALD, HD ;
LIPPMAN, ME ;
REICHERT, CM ;
DANGELO, T ;
GORRELL, CR ;
GERBER, NL ;
LICHTER, AS ;
ROSENBERG, SA ;
DEMOSS, ES .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 1986, 4 (05) :655-662
[7]   SIGNIFICANCE OF IPSILATERAL BREAST-TUMOR RECURRENCE AFTER LUMPECTOMY [J].
FISHER, B ;
ANDERSON, S ;
FISHER, ER ;
REDMOND, C ;
WICKERHAM, DL ;
WOLMARK, N ;
MAMOUNAS, EP ;
DEUTSCH, M ;
MARGOLESE, R .
LANCET, 1991, 338 (8763) :327-331
[8]   5-YEAR RESULTS OF A RANDOMIZED CLINICAL-TRIAL COMPARING TOTAL MASTECTOMY AND SEGMENTAL MASTECTOMY WITH OR WITHOUT RADIATION IN THE TREATMENT OF BREAST-CANCER [J].
FISHER, B ;
BAUER, M ;
MARGOLESE, R ;
POISSON, R ;
PILCH, Y ;
REDMOND, C ;
FISHER, E ;
WOLMARK, N ;
DEUTSCH, M ;
MONTAGUE, E ;
SAFFER, E ;
WICKERHAM, L ;
LERNER, H ;
GLASS, A ;
SHIBATA, H ;
DECKERS, P ;
KETCHAM, A ;
OISHI, R ;
RUSSELL, I .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1985, 312 (11) :665-673
[9]   8-YEAR RESULTS OF A RANDOMIZED CLINICAL-TRIAL COMPARING TOTAL MASTECTOMY AND LUMPECTOMY WITH OR WITHOUT IRRADIATION IN THE TREATMENT OF BREAST-CANCER [J].
FISHER, B ;
REDMOND, C ;
POISSON, R ;
MARGOLESE, R ;
WOLMARK, N ;
WICKERHAM, L ;
FISHER, E ;
DEUTSCH, M ;
CAPLAN, R ;
PILCH, Y ;
GLASS, A ;
SHIBATA, H ;
LERNER, H ;
TERZ, J ;
SIDOROVICH, L .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1989, 320 (13) :822-828
[10]   10 YEAR RESULTS OF CONSERVATIVE SURGERY AND IRRADIATION FOR STAGE-I AND STAGE-II BREAST-CANCER [J].
FOWBLE, BL ;
SOLIN, LJ ;
SCHULTZ, DJ ;
GOODMAN, RL .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RADIATION ONCOLOGY BIOLOGY PHYSICS, 1991, 21 (02) :269-277