MONEY MATTERS - A METAANALYTIC REVIEW OF THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FINANCIAL COMPENSATION AND THE EXPERIENCE AND TREATMENT OF CHRONIC PAIN

被引:129
作者
ROHLING, ML
BINDER, LM
LANGHINRICHSENROHLING, J
机构
[1] DEPT VET AFFAIRS MED CTR,PSYCHOL SERV,PORTLAND,OR
[2] DEPT VET AFFAIRS MED CTR,CHRON PAIN MANAGEMENT PROGRAM,PORTLAND,OR
关键词
ACCIDENT-NEUROSIS; TRAUMATIC-NEUROSIS; COMPENSATION-NEUROSIS; CHRONIC PAIN; DISABILITY; COMPENSATION; LITIGATION;
D O I
10.1037/0278-6133.14.6.537
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
Meta-analytic procedures were used to determine the relation between disability compensation and pain. Of the 157 relevant identified studies, only 32 contained quantifiable data from treatment and control groups. The majority of these exclusively examined chronic low back pain patients (72%). Overall, 136 comparisons were obtained, on the basis of 3,802 pain patients and 3,849 controls. Liberal procedures for estimating effect sizes (ESs) yielded an ES of .60 (p < .0002). Conservative procedures yielded an ES of .48 (p < .0005). Both ESs differed from zero, indicating that compensation is related to increased reports of pain and decreased treatment efficacy. These results are interpreted in light of current models of pain. Health policy implications are also discussed.
引用
收藏
页码:537 / 547
页数:11
相关论文
共 54 条
[1]  
ABENHAIM L, 1987, J OCCUP ENVIRON MED, V29, P670
[2]   FACTORS PREDICTING SHORT-TERM OUTCOME OF NERVE BLOCKS IN THE MANAGEMENT OF CHRONIC PAIN [J].
ABRAM, SE ;
ANDERSON, RA ;
MAITRADCRUZE, AM .
PAIN, 1981, 10 (03) :323-330
[3]  
BEALS RK, 1984, WESTERN J MED, V140, P233
[4]   BEHAVIORAL TREATMENT OF CHRONIC PAIN - VARIABLES AFFECTING TREATMENT EFFICACY [J].
BLOCK, AR ;
KREMER, E ;
GAYLOR, M .
PAIN, 1980, 8 (03) :367-375
[5]   RELATIVE CONTRIBUTION OF SPECIFIC AND NONSPECIFIC TREATMENT EFFECTS - META-ANALYSIS OF PLACEBO-CONTROLLED BEHAVIOR-THERAPY RESEARCH [J].
BOWERS, TG ;
CLUM, GA .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1988, 103 (03) :315-323
[6]  
BRENA SF, 1980, B LA NEUROL SOC, V44, P48
[7]  
BURKE FD, 1976, BRIT J CLIN PRACT, V30, P29
[8]   A COMPARISON OF LOW-BACK PAIN PATIENTS IN THE UNITED-STATES AND NEW-ZEALAND - PSYCHOSOCIAL AND ECONOMIC-FACTORS AFFECTING SEVERITY OF DISABILITY [J].
CARRON, H ;
DEGOOD, DE ;
TAIT, R .
PAIN, 1985, 21 (01) :77-89
[9]   TREATMENT OUTCOME IN A CHRONIC PAIN REHABILITATION PROGRAM [J].
CHAPMAN, SL ;
BRENA, SF ;
BRADFORD, LA .
PAIN, 1981, 11 (02) :255-268
[10]   LEARNED HELPLESSNESS AND RESPONSES TO NERVE BLOCKS IN CHRONIC LOW-BACK-PAIN PATIENTS [J].
CHAPMAN, SL ;
BRENA, SF .
PAIN, 1982, 14 (04) :355-364