Coxsackievirus infections have previously been shown to cause acute or chronic myocarditis in humans, and several mouse models have been established to study the pathology of this disease. Myocardial injury may result from direct viral effects and/or may be immune mediated, To determine the relative roles of these processes in pathogenesis, we have compared coxsackievirus B3 (CVB3) infections of normal and immuno-compromised transgenic knockout (ko) mice, CVB3 was able to infect all strains used (C57BL/6, CD4ko, and beta-microglobulin ko [beta 2Mko]), and following intraperitoneal injection, two disease processes could be distinguished, First, the virus caused early (3 to 7 days postinfection) death in a viral dose dependent manner, Immunocompetent C57BL/6 mice were highly susceptible (50% lethal dose = 70 PFU), while immunodeficient transgenic ko mice were less susceptible, showing 10- and 180-fold increases in the 50% lethal dose (for CD4ko and beta 2Mko mice, respectively), Second, a histologic examination of surviving CD4ko mice at 7 days postinfection revealed severe myocarditis; the inflammatory infiltrate comprised 40 to 50% macrophages, 30 to 40% NK cells, and 10 to 20% CD8(+) T lymphocytes, The infiltration resolved over the following 2 to 3 weeks, with resultant myocardial fibrosis, In vivo depletion of CD8(+) T lymphocytes from these CD4ko mice led to a marked reduction in myocarditis and an increase in myocardial virus titers. beta 2Mko mice, which lack antiviral CD8(+) T cells, are much less susceptible to early death and to the development of myocarditis. We conclude that our data support a strong immunopathologic component in CVB3-induced disease and implicate both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells, Compared with immunocompetent animals, (i) mice lacking CD4(+) T cells (CD4ko) were more resistant to virus challenge, and (ii) mice lacking CD8(+) T cells (beta Mko and in vivo-depleted CD4ko) showed enhanced survival and a reduced incidence of the later myocarditis. Nevertheless, the picture is complex, since (iii) removal of the CD4(+) component, while protecting against early death, greatly magnified the severity of myocarditis, and (iv) removal of the CD8(+) cells from CD4ko mice, although protecting against early death and later myocarditis, led to markedly increased virus titers in the heart, These data underscore the complex balance between the costs and benefits of effective antiviral immune responses.
