MEASUREMENT ISSUES IN CROSS-NATIONAL RESEARCH

被引:335
作者
SINGH, J
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8490188
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Substantive inferences from cross-national studies have important implications for theory (e.g., because they reveal insights into generalizability and boundary conditions) and managerial practice (e.g., because they offer guidelines to MNC managers). However, few empirical studies attend to measurement issues involved in cross-national research, and still fe,ver recognize the risk of inferential errors that are likely to occur by overlooking measurement issues. We discuss four measurement issues, namely (1) standardized versus unstandardized coefficients, (2) the impact of measurement error and unequal reliability, (3) the overall error rate and simultaneous analysis and (4) construct equivalence. Using illustrative examples we demonstrate the nature of each of these problems, the likely impact they can have on substantive conclusions, and approaches for tackling these problems. Additionally, we reanalyze a recently published three-nation study by Dubinsky, Michaels, Kotabe, Lim and Moon [1992] to clarify these measurement concerns, highlight a methodological approach, and delineate the extent and severity of inferential errors. Our reanalysis shows that the interactive effects of these measurement issues are pervasive, complex and unpredictable. We close with implications for cross-national research in general.
引用
收藏
页码:597 / 619
页数:23
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]   A TYPOLOGY OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES INVOLVING CULTURE [J].
ADLER, NJ .
JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS STUDIES, 1983, 14 (02) :29-47
[2]  
ALWIN DF, 1988, COMMON PROBLEMS PROP
[3]  
Bentler P. M., 1989, EQS STRUCTURAL EQUAT
[4]  
Bollen K.A., 1989, STRUCTURAL EQUATIONS
[5]   COMPARATIVE RESEARCH METHODOLOGY - CROSS-CULTURAL STUDIES [J].
BRISLIN, RW .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 1976, 11 (03) :215-229
[7]   MULTITRAIT-MULTIMETHOD COMPARISONS ACROSS POPULATIONS - A CONFIRMATORY FACTOR ANALYTIC APPROACH [J].
COLE, DA ;
MAXWELL, SE .
MULTIVARIATE BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH, 1985, 20 (04) :389-417
[8]   MEASURE UNRELIABILITY - A HIDDEN THREAT TO CROSS-NATIONAL MARKETING-RESEARCH [J].
DAVIS, HL ;
DOUGLAS, SP ;
SILK, AJ .
JOURNAL OF MARKETING, 1981, 45 (02) :98-109
[9]   EQUIVALENCE OF PSYCHOLOGICAL-MEASUREMENT IN HETEROGENEOUS POPULATIONS [J].
DRASGOW, F ;
KANFER, R .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY, 1985, 70 (04) :662-680
[10]   INFLUENCE OF ROLE STRESS ON INDUSTRIAL SALESPEOPLE WORK OUTCOMES IN THE UNITED-STATES, JAPAN, AND KOREA [J].
DUBINSKY, AJ ;
MICHAELS, RE ;
KOTABE, M ;
LIM, CU ;
MOON, HC .
JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS STUDIES, 1992, 23 (01) :77-99