RENAL-ALLOGRAFT SCINTIGRAPHY WITH TC-99M-DTPA - ITS ROLE DURING CYCLOSPORINE THERAPY

There are no accurate noninvasive methods to distinguish renal allograft dysfunction due to rejection or cyclosporine nephrotoxicity. We have studied the value of Tc-99M-DTPA renal scanning in 90 episodes of renal allograft dysfunction occurring in 44 patients subjected to 57 renal biopsies in whom a clear diagnosis could be established. Renal scintigrams were assessed qualitatively and quantitatively by a blinded observer. Rejection was diagnosed when deterioration in perfusion occurred in the presence of maintained or declining radio-nuclide excretion. The diagnosis of cyclosporine nephrotoxicity was made by exclusion. The final diagnosis was based on the clinical response to therapy and/ or the findings on renal biopsy. The scintigraphic diagnosis of rejection had a specificity of 87.9% and significantly contributed to the exclusion of cyclosporine nephrotoxicity (negative predictive value of 90.6%). Furthermore, a scintigraphic diagnosis compatible with cyclosporine nephrotoxicity, in the presence of a drug level above the therapeutic range, indicated a 90.4% probability of true nephrotoxicity. We conclude that, even in cyclosporine-treated renal transplant patients, Tc-99M-DTPA scintigraphy is of clinical value and can be incorporated into an effective diagnostic algorithm for allograft dysfunction.