SYSTEMATIC TRAINING OF GRADUATE-LEVEL COUNSELORS - NARRATIVE AND META-ANALYTIC REVIEWS OF 3 MAJOR PROGRAMS

This study reviews research on Carkhuff’s Human Resource Training/Human Resource Development (HRT/HRD), Kagan’s Interpersonal Process Recall (IPR), and Ivey’s Microcounseling (MC) programs, in all of which the trainees were graduate-level counselors. Both narrative and meta-analytic reviewing approaches were used. What has been accomplished thus far in each program is summed up, and future directions for training and research are suggested. All three programs were found effective overall with the meta-analysis categorizing the effects of HRT/HRD as large, of IPR as small, and of MC as a medium. Beyond overall effects; the narrative and meta-analytic reviews tended to focus on different variables, calling reviewer and reader attention to differing concerns and recommendations. It was concluded that there is more work to be accomplished with all three training programs when used with graduate-level counselors, and both methods of research integration should be understood for what they do and do not offer and used accordingly. © 1990, Sage Publications. All rights reserved.