PORTACAVAL-SHUNT VERSUS ENDOSCOPIC SCLEROTHERAPY IN THE ELECTIVE TREATMENT OF VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE

被引:59
作者
PLANAS, R
BOIX, J
BROGGI, M
CABRE, E
GOMESVIEIRA, MC
MORILLAS, R
ARMENGOL, M
DELEON, R
HUMBERT, P
SALVA, JA
GASSULL, MA
机构
[1] HOSP UNIV GERMANS TRIAS & PUJOT,DEPT GASTROENTEROL,CARRETERA CANYET S-N,E-08916 BADALONA,SPAIN
[2] HOSP UNIV GERMANS TRIAS & PUJOL,DEPT SURG,E-08916 BADALONA,SPAIN
关键词
D O I
10.1016/0016-5085(91)90285-S
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
Eighty-two consecutive Child-Campbell class A and B cirrhotic patients were included in a prospective controlled trial to assess the efficacy and safety of portacaval anastomosis vs. endoscopic sclerotherapy as elective treatment of variceal hemorrhage. Forty-one patients were randomized to portacaval anastomosis and 41 to sclerotherapy. After excluding dropouts, 34 patients were treated with portacaval anastomosis and 35 with sclerotherapy. The incidence of variceal rebleeding during follow-up (mean ± SD, 20.6 ± 14.2 months) was significantly higher in the sclerotherapy than in the portacaval groups, either considering the overall treated group or only patients completing sclerotherapy (40% and 25% vs. 2.9%; P = 0.0002 and P = 0.01, respectively). The 2-year probability of suffering from at least one episode of hepatic encephalopathy was significantly higher in patients submitted to portacaval anastomosis than in those treated with endoscopic sclerotherapy (40% vs. 12%; P = 0.04). However, disabling encephalopathy only appeared in 3 of 34 patients who underwent surgery (8.8%). Early and long-term mortality did not differ between the therapeutic groups; 2-year survival rates were 83% for portacaval anastomosis and 79% for sclerotherapy. It is concluded that portacaval anastomosis is more effective than endoscopic sclerotherapy in preventing variceal rebleeding in spite of the greater incidence of hepatic encephalopathy. The role of portacaval anastomosis in the elective treatment of variceal rebleeding should be reassessed. © 1991.
引用
收藏
页码:1078 / 1086
页数:9
相关论文
共 24 条
[1]  
BOIX J, 1988, MED CLIN-BARCELONA, V91, P614
[2]   SURVIVAL PREDICTION IN PORTACAVAL SHUNTS - COMPUTERIZED STATISTICAL-ANALYSIS [J].
CAMPBELL, DP ;
PARKER, DE ;
ANAGNOSTOPOULOS, CE .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 1973, 126 (06) :748-751
[3]   ENDOSCOPIC SCLEROTHERAPY VERSUS PORTACAVAL-SHUNT IN PATIENTS WITH SEVERE CIRRHOSIS AND ACUTE VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE - LONG-TERM FOLLOW-UP [J].
CELLO, JP ;
GRENDELL, JH ;
CRASS, RA ;
WEBER, TE ;
TRUNKEY, DD .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1987, 316 (01) :11-15
[4]  
CHRISTENSEN E, 1981, GASTROENTEROLOGY, V81, P944
[5]   PROGNOSTIC FACTORS IN UPPER GI BLEEDING [J].
DEDOMBAL, FT ;
CLARKE, JR ;
CLAMP, SE ;
MALIZIA, G ;
KOTWAL, MR ;
MORGAN, AG .
ENDOSCOPY, 1986, 18 :6-10
[6]   DISTAL SPLENORENAL VS PORTAL-SYSTEMIC SHUNTS AFTER HEMORRHAGE FROM VARICES - A RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL [J].
GRACE, ND ;
CONN, HO ;
RESNICK, RH ;
GROSZMANN, RJ ;
ATTERBURY, CE ;
WRIGHT, SC ;
GUSBERG, RJ ;
VOLLMAN, R ;
GARCIATSAO, G ;
FISHER, RL ;
OHARA, ET ;
MCDERMOTT, WV ;
MASELLI, JP ;
WIDRICH, W ;
MATLOFF, DS ;
HORST, D ;
BANKS, N ;
ALBERTS, J .
HEPATOLOGY, 1988, 8 (06) :1475-1481
[7]   RESULTS OF A RANDOMIZED TRIAL OF END-TO-SIDE PORTACAVAL-SHUNT AND DISTAL SPLENORENAL SHUNT IN ALCOHOLIC LIVER-DISEASE AND VARICEAL BLEEDING [J].
HARLEY, HAJ ;
MORGAN, T ;
REDEKER, AG ;
REYNOLDS, TB ;
VILLAMIL, F ;
WEINER, JM ;
YELLIN, A .
GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1986, 91 (04) :802-809
[8]   ENDOSCOPIC VARICEAL SCLEROSIS COMPARED WITH DISTAL SPLENORENAL SHUNT TO PREVENT RECURRENT VARICEAL BLEEDING IN CIRRHOSIS - A PROSPECTIVE, RANDOMIZED TRIAL [J].
HENDERSON, JM ;
KUTNER, MH ;
MILLIKAN, WJ ;
GALAMBOS, JT ;
RIEPE, SP ;
BROOKS, WS ;
BRYAN, FC ;
WARREN, WD .
ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 1990, 112 (04) :262-269
[9]   CLINICAL INVESTIGATION OF PORTACAVAL SHUNT .5. SURVIVAL ANALYSIS OF THERAPEUTIC OPERATION [J].
JACKSON, FC ;
PERRIN, EB ;
FELIX, WR ;
SMITH, AG .
ANNALS OF SURGERY, 1971, 174 (04) :672-&
[10]   A PROSPECTIVE, RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL OF CHRONIC ESOPHAGEAL VARICEAL SCLEROTHERAPY [J].
KORULA, J ;
BALART, LA ;
RADVAN, G ;
ZWEIBAN, BE ;
LARSON, AW ;
KAO, HW ;
YAMADA, S .
HEPATOLOGY, 1985, 5 (04) :584-589