GASTRIC-ULCER HEALING - A COMPARISON OF ENPROSTIL VERSUS RANITIDINE

被引:5
作者
BARDHAN, KD
WALKER, R
HINCHLIFFE, RFC
BOSE, K
MORRIS, P
THOMPSON, M
MILLER, JP
TOIVANEN, E
THOMPSON, RPH
PATRIER, P
PIKKARAINEN, P
KEYRILAINEN, O
YLIUOTILA, R
SWAN, CHJ
KLEPPING, C
TARPILA, S
THOMSON, MH
HARRIS, S
MASSEY, HC
IPE, D
机构
[1] WALTON HOSP,LIVERPOOL L9 1AE,MERSEYSIDE,ENGLAND
[2] WITHINGTON HOSP,MANCHESTER M20 8LR,LANCS,ENGLAND
[3] ST THOMAS HOSP,LONDON SE1 7EH,ENGLAND
[4] CITY GEN HOSP,STOKE ON TRENT ST4 6QG,STAFFS,ENGLAND
[5] SYNTEX INC,PALO ALTO,CA 94304
[6] KANTA HAMEEN KESKUSSAIRAALA,HAMEENLINNA,FINLAND
[7] UNIV ROUEN HAUTE NORMANDIE,CHR,ROUEN,FRANCE
[8] KUOPIO YLIOPISTOLLINEN KESKUSSAIRAALA,KUOPIO,FINLAND
[9] TAMPEREEN YLIOPISTOLLINEN KESKUSSAIRAALA,TAMPERE,FINLAND
[10] ETALA POHJANMAAN KESKUSSAIRAALA,SEINAJOKI,FINLAND
[11] HOSP GEN,DIJON,FRANCE
[12] DIAKONISSALALAITOKSEN,HELSINKI,FINLAND
[13] SYNTEX RES EUROPE,MAIDENHEAD,ENGLAND
关键词
GASTRIC ULCER; CLINICAL TRIAL; FACTORS AFFECTING HEALING; ENPROSTIL; RANITIDINE;
D O I
10.1097/00004836-199104000-00008
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
Enprostil is a synthetic prostaglandin E2 analogue with gastric antisecretory and mucosal protective properties. We compared the effects of enprostil and ranitidine on the healing of gastric ulcers and the subsequent relapse rates over 6 months. Patients (N = 156) were recruited for a double-blind study from 12 centers in Europe; 71 were randomly assigned to oral treatment with 35-mu-g enprostil twice daily and 85 to 150 mg ranitidine twice daily for up to 8 weeks. Both groups were of similar demography; their healing rates were also similar. Cumulative intent-to-treat healing rates were at 4 weeks enprostil 48%, ranitidine 41%; at 6 weeks enprostil 65%, ranitidine 68%; and at 8 weeks enprostil 72%, ranitidine 80%. Of those patients who met all protocol criteria and completed treatment, and were endoscoped at the prescribed times, healing rates were at 4 weeks enprostil 55%, ranitidine 54%, at 6 weeks enprostil 75%, ranitidine 84%; and at 8 weeks enprostil 80%, ranitidine 90%. Relief of pain was rapid and similar in both groups. The incidence of adverse events was low and similar in the two groups. The treatment-free relapse rate at 6 months was enprostil 64%, ranitidine 49%; the median times to relapse were 169 and 203 days, respectively. Enprostil and ranitidine appear to be equally effective in healing gastric ulcers.
引用
收藏
页码:157 / 162
页数:6
相关论文
共 26 条
[1]  
BARDHAN KD, 1987, J CLIN GASTROENTEROL, V10, P137
[2]   PROTECTION AGAINST ASPIRIN-INDUCED ANTRAL AND DUODENAL DAMAGE WITH ENPROSTIL - A DOUBLE-BLIND ENDOSCOPIC STUDY [J].
COHEN, MM ;
MCCREADY, DR ;
CLARK, L ;
SEVELIUS, H .
GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1985, 88 (01) :382-386
[3]   COMPARATIVE CLINICAL-TRIAL OF ENPROSTIL AND RANITIDINE IN THE TREATMENT OF GASTRIC-ULCER [J].
DAMMANN, HG ;
HUTTEMANN, W ;
KALEK, HD ;
ROHNER, HG ;
SIMON, B .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1986, 81 (2A) :80-84
[4]  
DAVIS G R, 1982, Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics, V31, P215
[5]  
DAVIS GR, 1984, GASTROENTEROLOGY, V86, P1058
[6]   EFFECT OF ENPROSTIL, A SYNTHETIC PROSTAGLANDIN-E2 ON 24-HOUR INTRAGASTRIC ACIDITY, NOCTURNAL ACID AND PEPSIN-SECRETION [J].
DEAKIN, M ;
RAMAGE, J ;
PAUL, A ;
GRAY, SP ;
BILLINGS, J ;
WILLIAMS, JG .
GUT, 1986, 27 (09) :1054-1057
[7]  
DIXON WJ, 1981, BMDP STATISTICAL SOF
[8]   REDUCTION BY ENPROSTIL OF ASPIRIN-INDUCED BLOOD-LOSS FROM HUMAN GASTRIC-MUCOSA [J].
HAWKEY, CJ ;
SIMPSON, G ;
SOMERVILLE, KW .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1986, 81 (2A) :50-53
[9]  
HILLIER K, 1982, Drugs of the Future, V7, P812
[10]   THE TREATMENT OF GASTRIC-ULCER WITH ANTISECRETORY DRUGS - RELATIONSHIP OF PHARMACOLOGICAL EFFECT TO HEALING RATES [J].
HOWDEN, CW ;
JONES, DB ;
PEACE, KE ;
BURGET, DW ;
HUNT, RH .
DIGESTIVE DISEASES AND SCIENCES, 1988, 33 (05) :619-624