A LACK OF HETEROSIS IN NATURAL POPLAR HYBRIDS FROM SOUTHERN ALBERTA

Shoot cuttings were collected from 56 native poplars along 11 rivers and creeks in southwestern Alberta, a region where Populus angustifolia, Populus balsamifera (sspp. balsamifera and trichocarpa), and Populus deltoides form a disectional, trispecific hybrid swarm. Cuttings were rooted and established in an irrigated nursery plot. After 3 years, stem diameters and heights were measured from 381 trees and whole shoots were harvested from 74 trees to establish a regression equation relating basal diameter and shoot wet weight. Shoot wet weight varied by more than an order of magnitude across the clones, and P. angustifolia clones tended to grow more slowly than clones of the other two species. There was no significant correlation between shoot growth rate and the degree of hybridization, as determined by a prior multivariate analysis of leaf form that has been substantiated by chemotaxonomic data. Thus, the interspecific hybrids were not generally more vigorous than clones with leaf forms typical of the parental species P. deltoides or P. balsamifera. Conversely, in the same environment, artificial hybrids of P. deltoides from Illinois and P. balsamifera (ssp. trichocarpa) from Washington expressed heterosis. It is theorized that introgressive genetic exchange accompanying the natural interbreeding of these three poplar species in southern Alberta minimizes their genetic distance, preventing heterosis.