A TEST OF THE CONDITION-BIAS HYPOTHESIS USING BROWN-HEADED COWBIRDS TRAPPED DURING THE BREEDING-SEASON

We examined trap bias relative to body condition, age, and sex using data collected from Brown-headed Cowbirds (Molothrus ater) decoy trapped during the 1987 and 1988 breeding seasons. A condition bias was evident, as decoy-trapped birds were in poor condition relative to those caught by mist net in an adjacent roost. This occurred in both sexes and independently of study year and male age. Paradoxically, however, males in better condition when first trapped were more likely to be recaptured in the same season, possibly reflecting more widespread movement, and hence fewer encounters with traps, by birds in poor condition. Hatching-year birds were more likely than adults to be recaptured in the same season. Trapped samples were strongly male biased, which probably reflects a difference in nutritional requirements, and thus foraging strategies, between males and females during the breeding season. This study indicates that biases among birds trapped by methods that rely on a feeding response are likely to be widespread and difficult to predict, suggesting that interpretation of data from such samples always requires caution.