Phylogenetic incongruence between dinoflagellate endosymbionts (Symbiodinium) and their host foraminifera (Sorites): Small-subunit ribosomal RNA gene sequence evidence

Phototrophic dinoflagellate zooxanthellae commonly occur as endosymbionts in many planktic and certain benthic foraminifera (soritids). Many taxonomic issues and specific identities of foraminiferal dinoflagellates are not yet resolved. To assess taxonomic affinities among other dinoflagellates, we have determined the complete nucleotide sequence of the small-subunit rRNA coding region from Symbiodinium sp., an endosymbiotic dinoflagellate of the larger foraminifer Sorites orbiculus. The polymerase chain reaction was adopted for the in vitro amplification of ribosomal DNA, utilizing primers complementary to conserved regions. PCR-amplified DNA was directly sequenced and the sequence was aligned to all complete 18S-rDNA dinoflagellate sequences currently available through GenBank. Apicomplexan, ciliate, chromistacean, and rhodophycean sequences were added to infer across-kingdom phylogenetic relationships. Phylogenetic analysis of aligned nucleotide sequences produced a single most parsimonious tree (generated by the branch and bound method of PAUP). The inferred phylogeny indicates that the dinoflagellate extracted from the foraminifer Sorites orbiculus is a sister taxon to the symbiont present in the larger foraminifera Marginopora kudakajimaensis, but only distantly related to the dinoflagellate isolated from the soritid Amphisorus hemprichii. The sequence heterogeneity demonstrates a high degree of genetic diversity among Symbiodinium-like zooxanthellae and re-emphasizes that they are a variety of distinct entities. The inferred molecular phylogenetic relationships among symbiotic dinoflagellates are not congruent with the foraminiferal phylogeny based on cladistic methodology. The lack of correlation between the evolutionary history of dinoflagellate symbionts and their foraminiferal hosts argues against co-evolution. This lack of co-evolution implies that flexible recombinations among hosts and symbionts are evolutionarily favorable over permanently associated lineages, at least in these benthic foraminifera.