KNOWLEDGE-BASED VALIDATION OF PROTEIN-STRUCTURE COORDINATES DERIVED BY X-RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY AND NMR-SPECTROSCOPY

被引:85
作者
MACARTHUR, MW
LASKOWSKI, RA
THORNTON, JM
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1016/S0959-440X(94)90172-4
中图分类号
Q5 [生物化学]; Q7 [分子生物学];
学科分类号
071010 ; 081704 ;
摘要
Over the past few years, several protein structures solved by X-ray crystallography have been found to contain serious errors. This has prompted the development of methods for validating protein structures, in both the X-ray and NMR fields. A number of computational tools have recently been developed for assessing structures independently of the experimental data, thereby providing an additional, complementary check on their correctness. In effect, the tests assess the normality of a protein and are both local, checking the correctness of the local geometry, and global, verifying the overall fold. In structure determination by NMR the problems or validation are compounded by multiple solutions for the experimental data and lack of agreement over means of assessing the fit of the models to the data.
引用
收藏
页码:731 / 737
页数:7
相关论文
共 53 条
[1]   POLARITY AS A CRITERION IN PROTEIN DESIGN [J].
BAUMANN, G ;
FROMMEL, C ;
SANDER, C .
PROTEIN ENGINEERING, 1989, 2 (05) :329-334
[2]   PROTEIN DATA BANK - COMPUTER-BASED ARCHIVAL FILE FOR MACROMOLECULAR STRUCTURES [J].
BERNSTEIN, FC ;
KOETZLE, TF ;
WILLIAMS, GJB ;
MEYER, EF ;
BRICE, MD ;
RODGERS, JR ;
KENNARD, O ;
SHIMANOUCHI, T ;
TASUMI, M .
JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR BIOLOGY, 1977, 112 (03) :535-542
[3]   COMPARISON OF PROTEIN STRUCTURES DETERMINED BY NMR IN SOLUTION AND BY X-RAY-DIFFRACTION IN SINGLE-CRYSTALS [J].
BILLETER, M .
QUARTERLY REVIEWS OF BIOPHYSICS, 1992, 25 (03) :325-377
[4]   BETWEEN OBJECTIVITY AND SUBJECTIVITY [J].
BRANDEN, CI ;
JONES, TA .
NATURE, 1990, 343 (6260) :687-689
[5]   FREE R-VALUE - A NOVEL STATISTICAL QUANTITY FOR ASSESSING THE ACCURACY OF CRYSTAL-STRUCTURES [J].
BRUNGER, AT .
NATURE, 1992, 355 (6359) :472-475
[6]   ASSESSING THE QUALITY OF SOLUTION NUCLEAR-MAGNETIC-RESONANCE STRUCTURES BY COMPLETE CROSS-VALIDATION [J].
BRUNGER, AT ;
CLORE, GM ;
GRONENBORN, AM ;
SAFFRICH, R ;
NILGES, M .
SCIENCE, 1993, 261 (5119) :328-331
[7]   COMPUTATIONAL CHALLENGES FOR MACROMOLECULAR STRUCTURE DETERMINATION BY X-RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY AND SOLUTION NMR-SPECTROSCOPY [J].
BRUNGER, AT ;
NILGES, M .
QUARTERLY REVIEWS OF BIOPHYSICS, 1993, 26 (01) :49-125
[8]   PAP - A PROTEIN-ANALYSIS PACKAGE [J].
CALLAHAN, T ;
GLEASON, WB ;
LYBRAND, TP .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, 1990, 23 :434-436
[9]   EXPLORING THE LIMITS OF PRECISION AND ACCURACY OF PROTEIN STRUCTURES DETERMINED BY NUCLEAR-MAGNETIC-RESONANCE SPECTROSCOPY [J].
CLORE, GM ;
ROBIEN, MA ;
GRONENBORN, AM .
JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR BIOLOGY, 1993, 231 (01) :82-102
[10]   2-DIMENSIONAL, 3-DIMENSIONAL, AND 4-DIMENSIONAL NMR METHODS FOR OBTAINING LARGER AND MORE PRECISE 3-DIMENSIONAL STRUCTURES OF PROTEINS IN SOLUTION [J].
CLORE, GM ;
GRONENBORN, AM .
ANNUAL REVIEW OF BIOPHYSICS AND BIOPHYSICAL CHEMISTRY, 1991, 20 :29-63