Estimating survival rates from recoveries of birds ringed as young: A case study

Models for analysis of survival rates from recoveries of birds ringed as young were evaluated for lesser snow geese ringed on the breeding grounds at La Perouse Bay, Manitoba from 1970 to 1992. Analyses of birds ringed as adults and young indicate recovery rates were lower for young than for older birds and varied independently in the two age classes. Adult survival increased over the study, while that of immatures decreased. Using only recoveries of birds ringed as young, models incorporating observed variation in recovery rates were not identifiable. Many sets of constraints could be selected to make the model identifiable, but there was no objective way to distinguish among them, and each could lead to different conclusions. The observed changes in survival rates could not be estimated. Previous analyses have shown that models for birds ringed as young can be used to test even complex variation in survival rates, provided that recovery rates do not vary with age. Unfortunately, as shown by the geese, this assumption may often be violated and can only be tested with additional data, preferably from birds recaptured or ringed as sub-adults or adults.