The flowing afterglow technique, coupled with laser induced fluorescence (LIF) and vacuum ultraviolet (vuv) absorption spectroscopy, has been used to determine the fractional H-atom contributions, f(H), to the product distributions for the dissociative recombination of a series of protonated ions (N2H+, HCO+, HCO2+, N2OH+, OCSH+, H2CN+, H3O+, H3S+, NH4+, and CH5+) with electrons. The measurements were made at 300 K in two separate ways in two laboratories by (i) directly determining the H-atom number density using vuv absorption spectroscopy at the L-alpha (121.6 nm) wavelength and (ii) converting the H atoms to OH radicals using the reaction H + NO2 --> OH + NO followed by LIF to determine the OH number density. The agreement between the two techniques is excellent and values of f(H) varying from approximately 0.2 (for OCSH+) to 1.2 (for CH5+) have been obtained showing that in some of the cases recombination can lead to the ejection of two separate H atoms. Comparison of the oxygen/sulphur analogs, HCO2+/OCSH+ and H3O+/H3S+ showed that the f(H) values were very different. Possible reasons for these differences are discussed. Comparison is also made with the available theory.