ANALYSIS OF ANIONS IN NATURAL-WATERS - A COMPARISON OF METHODS INCLUDING IONCHROMATOGRAPHY AND CONTINUOUS-FLOW-TECHNICS

被引:2
作者
MAHR, A [1 ]
TURK, T [1 ]
DOBROWOLSKI, A [1 ]
HORN, R [1 ]
机构
[1] INST PFLANZENERNAHRUNG & BODENKUNDE,W-2300 KIEL 1,GERMANY
来源
ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PFLANZENERNAHRUNG UND BODENKUNDE | 1991年 / 154卷 / 05期
关键词
D O I
10.1002/jpln.19911540510
中图分类号
S3 [农学(农艺学)];
学科分类号
0901 ;
摘要
Using waters from different compartments of forest ecosystems, standard solutions, moreover samples containing known internal standards, several analytical methods were tested for the comparability of nitrate, sulfate and chloride results in an inter-laboratory study. The analytical instruments were ion chromatographs with and without suppression as well as continuous-flow-analyzers. A cluster analysis showed a strong correlation between the obtained data and the analytical method used for nitrate, and a poorer relation for sulfate. Concerning nitrate-analysis, the IC-systems showed a better detection limit and a higher recovery of standards. Mean standard deviation among all tested analytical methods was calculated to be 15 % for nitrate, 10 % for sulfate and 14 % for chloride. These results represent deviations as they may occur during laboratory routine analyses with a high amount of samples and the need for simultaneous determination of several anions. For the examined anions no significant correlation was obtained between the variation of the analytical results and the dissolved organic carbon concentrations of the samples.
引用
收藏
页码:369 / 375
页数:7
相关论文
共 14 条
[1]   THE EVALUATION AND COMPARISON OF ION CHROMATOGRAPHY, SEGMENTED FLOW-ANALYSIS AND FLOW-INJECTION ANALYSIS FOR THE DETERMINATION ON NITRATE IN NATURAL SURFACE WATERS [J].
BURKE, EM ;
SUAREZ, FX ;
HILLMAN, DC ;
HEITHMAR, EM .
WATER RESEARCH, 1989, 23 (04) :519-521
[2]  
GALLOWAY JN, 1978, TELLUS, V30, P71, DOI 10.1111/j.2153-3490.1978.tb00819.x
[3]   NITRATE CONTENT AND NITRATE REDUCTASE-ACTIVITY IN RUMEX-OBTUSIFOLIUS L .1. DIFFERENCES IN ORGANS AND DIURNAL CHANGES [J].
GEBAUER, G ;
MELZER, A ;
REHDER, H .
OECOLOGIA, 1984, 63 (01) :136-142
[4]   EXTENSION OF SAMPLE SIZES AND PERCENTAGE POINTS FOR SIGNIFICANCE TESTS OF OUTLYING OBSERVATIONS [J].
GRUBBS, FE ;
BECK, G .
TECHNOMETRICS, 1972, 14 (04) :847-&
[5]  
HANTSCHEL R, 1987, BAYREUTHER BODENKUND, V3, P1
[6]   SIMPLE METHOD FOR CONSTRUCTING PHYLOGENETIC TREES FROM DISTANCE MATRICES [J].
LI, WH .
PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES, 1981, 78 (02) :1085-1089
[7]  
MEIWES KJ, 1984, BERICHTE FORSCHUNGSZ, V7, P68
[8]  
Mohr H, 1986, BIOL UNSERER Z, V16, P83
[9]   METHODS FOR THE ANALYSIS OF INORGANIC ANIONS .5. COMPARISONS ABOUT THE EFFICIENCY OF ION CHROMATOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS SYSTEMS [J].
ROSSNER, B ;
SCHWEDT, G .
FRESENIUS ZEITSCHRIFT FUR ANALYTISCHE CHEMIE, 1985, 320 (06) :566-572
[10]   NOVEL ION-EXCHANGE CHROMATOGRAPHIC METHOD USING CONDUCTIMETRIC DETECTION [J].
SMALL, H ;
STEVENS, TS ;
BAUMAN, WC .
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, 1975, 47 (11) :1801-1809