FIELD INTERCOMPARISON OF FILTER PACK AND DENUDER SAMPLING METHODS FOR REACTIVE GASEOUS AND PARTICULATE POLLUTANTS

被引:115
作者
HARRISON, RM
KITTO, AMN
机构
[1] Institute of Aerosol Science, University of Essex, Colchester
来源
ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT PART A-GENERAL TOPICS | 1990年 / 24卷 / 10期
关键词
Ammonia; denuder; filter pack; hydrochloric acid; nitric acid;
D O I
10.1016/0960-1686(90)90142-A
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Atmospheric sulphate, nitrate, chloride and ammonium species have been measured with colocated filter pack and denuder samplers. In general the total amount of a species collected by the two types of sampler was almost the same, although there was evidence of better inlet efficiency for particles in the filter pack sampler. The filter pack gives slightly higher measurements of the volatile species HNO3, HCl and NH3 than the denuder, with a corresponding lower measure of particulate NO3-, Cl- and NH4+, attributable to volatilization of ammonium salts from the filter pack pre-filter. In the context of most ambient measurements, the divergences between the techniques are small, and it is argued that differences in these measurement techniques are inevitably site, operator and apparatus-specific and data from one site or research group cannot readily be extrapolated to other sites. © 1990.
引用
收藏
页码:2633 / 2640
页数:8
相关论文
共 29 条
[1]   ANNULAR DENUDER METHOD FOR SAMPLING REACTIVE GASES AND AEROSOLS IN THE ATMOSPHERE [J].
ALLEGRINI, I ;
DESANTIS, F ;
DIPALO, V ;
FEBO, A ;
PERRINO, C ;
POSSANZINI, M ;
LIBERTI, A .
SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT, 1987, 67 (01) :1-16
[2]  
ALLEGRINI I, 1985, ADV AIR POLLUTION MO
[3]   FIELD-MEASUREMENTS OF THE DISSOCIATION OF AMMONIUM-NITRATE AND AMMONIUM-CHLORIDE AEROSOLS [J].
ALLEN, AG ;
HARRISON, RM ;
ERISMAN, JW .
ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT, 1989, 23 (07) :1591-1599
[4]  
ALLEN AG, 1990, UNPUB
[5]   A COMPARISON OF 3 METHODS FOR MEASUREMENT OF ATMOSPHERIC NITRIC-ACID AND AEROSOL NITRATE AND AMMONIUM [J].
ANLAUF, KG ;
FELLIN, P ;
WIEBE, HA ;
SCHIFF, HI ;
MACKAY, GI ;
BRAMAN, RS ;
GILBERT, R .
ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT, 1985, 19 (02) :325-333
[6]   MEASUREMENT OF ATMOSPHERIC NITRIC-ACID BY THE FILTER METHOD AND COMPARISONS WITH THE TUNABLE DIODE-LASER AND OTHER METHODS [J].
ANLAUF, KG ;
MACTAVISH, DC ;
WIEBE, HA ;
SCHIFF, HI ;
MACKAY, GI .
ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT, 1988, 22 (08) :1579-1586
[7]   EVALUATION OF PROCEDURES FOR MEASURING ATMOSPHERIC NITRIC-ACID AND AMMONIA [J].
APPEL, BR ;
TOKIWA, Y ;
KOTHNY, EL ;
WU, R ;
POVARD, V .
ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT, 1988, 22 (08) :1565-1573
[8]   TUNGSTIC ACID FOR PRE-CONCENTRATION AND DETERMINATION OF GASEOUS AND PARTICULATE AMMONIA AND NITRIC-ACID IN AMBIENT AIR [J].
BRAMAN, RS ;
SHELLEY, TJ ;
MCCLENNY, WA .
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, 1982, 54 (03) :358-364
[9]   COMPARISON OF ANNULAR DENUDERS AND FILTER PACKS FOR ATMOSPHERIC SAMPLING [J].
DASCH, JM ;
CADLE, SH ;
KENNEDY, KG ;
MULAWA, PA .
ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT, 1989, 23 (12) :2775-2782
[10]   NITRIC-ACID NITRATE AEROSOL MEASUREMENTS BY A DIFFUSION DENUDER - A PERFORMANCE EVALUATION [J].
DURHAM, JL ;
SPILLER, LL ;
ELLESTAD, TG .
ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT, 1987, 21 (03) :589-598