An effective enzymatic strategy for eliminating the common acetaminophen interference in amperometric sensing is described. The method relies on the in situ biocatalytic removal of acetaminophen by the surface-bound tyrosinase. Mushroom-containing carbon paste electrodes (rich with tyrosinase) are particularly useful for eliminating contributions from acetaminophen. Various factors affecting the efficiency of the tyrosinase-based elimination capability are explored. Selective biosensing of glucose is accomplished by the coimmobilization of glucose oxidase.