A MULTILEVEL ANALYSIS OF SCHOOL EXAMINATION RESULTS

被引:100
作者
GOLDSTEIN, H
RASBASH, J
YANG, M
WOODHOUSE, G
PAN, HQ
NUTTALL, D
THOMAS, S
机构
[1] University of London Institute of Education, London WC1H 0AL
关键词
D O I
10.1080/0305498930190401
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
Data on examination results from inner London schools are analysed in relation to intake achievement, pupil gender and school type. The examination achievement, averaged over subjects, is studied as is achievement in the separate subjects of mathematics and English. Multilevel models are fitted so that the variation between schools can be studied. It is shown that confidence intervals for school 'residuals' or 'effects' are wide, so that few schools can be separated reliably. In particular, no fine rank ordering of schools legitimately can be produced. A bivariate model for mathematics and English examination achievement scores is fitted The student level variance for both subjects is shown to increase from the lowest to the highest intake achievement group, with moderately high correlation between the subjects. Tbe paper discusses the implications of these findings for the publication of 'league tables' of school examination and test scores.
引用
收藏
页码:425 / 433
页数:9
相关论文
共 8 条
[1]   STATISTICAL MODELING ISSUES IN SCHOOL EFFECTIVENESS STUDIES [J].
AITKIN, M ;
LONGFORD, N ;
PLEWIS, IF ;
WAKEFIELD, WB ;
CHATFIELD, C ;
GOLDSTEIN, H ;
REYNOLDS, D ;
COX, D ;
ECOB, R ;
GRAY, J ;
BELL, JF ;
BURSTEIN, L ;
DAWID, AP ;
HEALY, MJR ;
HUTCHISON, DA ;
KILGORE, S ;
PENDLETON, WW ;
LAIRD, NM ;
LOUIS, TA ;
PRAIS, SJ ;
RUTTER, M ;
MAUGHAN, B ;
OUSTON, J ;
SHARE, DL ;
SMITH, TMF .
JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL STATISTICAL SOCIETY SERIES A-STATISTICS IN SOCIETY, 1986, 149 :1-43
[2]  
Goldstein H., 1987, MULTILEVEL MODELS ED
[3]   ESTIMATING DIFFERENCES IN THE EXAMINATION PERFORMANCES OF SECONDARY-SCHOOLS IN 6 LEAS - A MULTILEVEL APPROACH TO SCHOOL EFFECTIVENESS [J].
GRAY, J ;
JESSON, D ;
SIME, N .
OXFORD REVIEW OF EDUCATION, 1990, 16 (02) :137-158
[4]  
KREFT JGG, 1990, COMP 4 DIFFERENT STA
[5]  
Levy P., 1984, TESTS ED
[6]  
Nuttall D.L., 1989, INT J EDUC RES, V13, P769, DOI DOI 10.1016/0883-0355(89)90027-X
[7]  
Prosser R. J, 1991, ML3 SOFTWARE 3 LEVEL
[8]  
YANG M, 1993, UNPUB ADJUSTING MEAS