Fifty-five acid soil horizons from 19 profiles were evaluated for aluminum toxicity using root elongation as a criterion in a two-day petri dish bioassay. The method proved to be simple, efficient, and precise enough to clearly distinguish aluminum toxicity differences among horizons within and between profiles. Although toxicity patterns within profiles differed, it was common for surface horizons to be less toxic even when very acid. The R 2 for correlations of relative root lengths with pH in H 2O, pH in KCl, soluble and exchangeable aluminum and percent aluminum saturation were only 0.42, 0.45, 0.52, 0.66, and 0.54, respectively, which indicates the need for a bioassay. In a further use of the method, and to demonstrate its efficiency, 243 horizons from 26 profiles were screened. Approximately half of the horizons with a pH of 5.0 or below showed Al toxicity. When used by different operators, with a variety of soil and treatment parameter changes, the two-day bioassay in petri dishes gave consistent rankings of soils by degree of aluminum toxicity. © 1990 Kluwer Academic Publishers.