PATIENTS WHO INITIALLY REFUSE PREHOSPITAL EVALUATION AND OR THERAPY

被引:29
作者
STARK, G [1 ]
HEDGES, JR [1 ]
NEELY, K [1 ]
NORTON, R [1 ]
机构
[1] OREGON HLTH SCI UNIV,DIV EMERGENCY MED,3181 SW SAM JACKSON PK RD,PORTLAND,OR 97201
关键词
Emergency medical services (EMS) Systems; legal hold; medical legal; mental capacity; prehospital care; refusal of medical care;
D O I
10.1016/0735-6757(90)90152-P
中图分类号
R4 [临床医学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100602 ;
摘要
The authors performed a retrospective descriptive and analytical cohort study of prehospital patient initial refusal of care (PIRC) cases to characterize the types of patients encountered and to assess factors associated with their dispositions. During a 6-month period, 169 of 1715 (9.9%) base station calls in an urban emergency medical service (EMS) system were for physician involvement in a PIRC. Patients' dispositions were as follows: left at scene against medical advice (53%); taken by ambulance to the hospital (28%); left with friend (13%); other disposition (5%). While police were called to the scene 41 times, they placed a "legal hold" on only 10 patients. Leaving the patient at the scene against medical advice was associated (logistic regression analysis; P < .05) with the absence of the following factors: family on the scene and a police hold, and with the presence of the following factors: treated hypoglycemia, alcohol use, orlentation, and normal speech. The development of statutes that allow police hold placement under the guidance of the base station physician may be necessary. Such statutes would aid transportation of a patient considered by EMS personnel to have impaired mental capacity that may limit the patient's ability to understand medical care decisions. © 1990.
引用
收藏
页码:509 / 511
页数:3
相关论文
共 12 条
[1]  
Holroyd, Shalit, Kallsen, Et al., Prehospital patients refusing care, Ann Emerg Med, 17, pp. 957-963, (1988)
[2]  
Drane, Competency to give an informed consent, JAMA, 252, pp. 925-927, (1984)
[3]  
George, Consent to treatment, Law and Emergency Care, pp. 35-50, (1980)
[4]  
Griglak, Bucci, Medicolegal management of the organically impaired patient in the emergency department, Ann Emerg Med, 14, pp. 685-689, (1985)
[5]  
Purdie, Honigman, Rosen, Et al., Prudent handling of patients signing out against medical advice, ER Reports, 3, pp. 73-78, (1982)
[6]  
Dernocoeur, Pitfalls of refusals, JEMS, 7, pp. 79-83, (1982)
[7]  
Berne, Prehospital emergency treatment of people who say “no, thank you”, Emerg Med Serv, 15, pp. 62-65, (1986)
[8]  
Iserson, Sanders, Mathieu, Autonomy and informed consent, Ethics in Emergency Medicine, pp. 45-47, (1986)
[9]  
Brock, Informed participation in decisions, Ethics in Emergency Medicine, pp. 47-52, (1986)
[10]  
Soler, Montes, Egol, Et al., The ten-year malpractice experience of a large urban EMS system, Ann Emerg Med, 14, pp. 982-985, (1985)