VARYING DOSE-RESPONSE CHARACTERISTICS OF DIFFERENT IMMUNOASSAYS AND AN INVITRO BIOASSAY FOR FSH ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR CHANGING RATIOS OF BIOLOGICALLY-ACTIVE TO IMMUNOLOGICALLY ACTIVE FSH

Serum FSH levels in fertile and infertile men were determined by applying the Sertoli cell in-vitro bioassay and six different immunoassays. Bioassay and immunoassay estimates were significantly correlated (r ranging from 0.78 to 0.86; P < 0.01). On average, all immunoassays measured lower FSH concentrations in samples with low FSH levels and higher FSH concentrations in those with high FSH levels compared with the bioassay. Ratios of bioactivity to immunoreactivity (B/I) were highest in fertile men and lowest in men with severe disturbances of testicular function. Depending on which immunoassay was used these differences were either significant or only marginal. Dose-response characteristics for WHO FSH standard preparation 78/549, used in the bioassay as well as in the immunoassays, were different between immunoassays and the bioassay, suggesting that decreasing B/I ratios with increasing FSH serum levels were method-related and reflected different slopes of the dose-response characteristics of the assays, rather than being true changes in the molecular composition of FSH. The present investigation underlines the necessity of choosing the immunoassay used for comparison with the bioassay carefully and of validating the system in regard to parallelism between dose-response characteristics. B/I ratios must be interpreted with great caution and previous studies which report changing B/I ratios in various endocrine situations may have to be reevaluated.