RABIES CONTROL IN THE REPUBLIC-OF-THE-PHILIPPINES - BENEFITS AND COSTS OF ELIMINATION

被引:30
作者
FISHBEIN, DB
MIRANDA, NJ
MERRILL, P
CAMBA, RA
MELTZER, M
CARLOS, ET
BAUTISTA, CF
SOPUNGCO, PV
MANGAHAS, LC
HERNANDEZ, LM
LEONCIO, MM
MERCADO, D
GREGORIO, S
SALVA, E
DOBBINS, JG
WINKLER, WG
机构
[1] DEPT AGR,BUR ANIM IND,MANILA,PHILIPPINES
[2] NATL RABIES COMM,BUR ANIM IND,MANILA,PHILIPPINES
[3] DEPT HLTH,FIELD EPIDEMIOL TRAINING PROGRAM,MANILA,PHILIPPINES
[4] RES INST TROP MED,DEPT HLTH,MANILA,PHILIPPINES
[5] DEPT HLTH,BIOL PROD SERV,MANILA,PHILIPPINES
[6] PRICE WATERHOUSE & CO,NEW YORK,NY 10020
[7] DEPT HLTH,OFF PUBL HLTH,MANILA,PHILIPPINES
[8] UNIV FLORIDA,COLL VET MED,GAINESVILLE,FL 32611
关键词
RABIES; ELIMINATION; PROGRAM; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; PHILIPPINES; RABIES VACCINE; DOG DISEASES;
D O I
10.1016/0264-410X(91)90246-3
中图分类号
R392 [医学免疫学]; Q939.91 [免疫学];
学科分类号
100102 ;
摘要
We compared the benefits and costs of eliminating animal and human rabies in the Philippines. If rabies had been eliminated in 1988, economic benefits would total P52.8 (US$2.5) million in 1989. These benefits would largely arise from the abolition of expenses associated with rabies prevention: P29.7 (US$1.4) million for animal vaccination, P21.6 (US$1.0) million for human postexposure prophylaxis, and P0.3 (US$0.02) million for animal rabies examinations. Benefits also included P1.2 (US$0.06) million in additional earnings of humans whose death due to rabies would be prevented. Nationwide elimination was estimated to cost between P88.1 (US$4.2) million and P317.2 (US$15.0) million, assuming a canine-to-human ratio of 1:10, vaccine coverage of 60%, and a cost per vaccination of no less than P25 (US$1.19) and no more than P90 (US$4.27). These costs would be recouped 4.1-11.0 years after the initiation of a one-year elimination campaign. A sensitivity analysis showed that an elimination programme would be economically beneficial in all but the most extreme cases.
引用
收藏
页码:581 / 587
页数:7
相关论文
共 22 条
[1]  
ARAMBULO PN, 1971, J PHILIPP MED, V47, P206
[2]  
BELOTTO AJ, 1988, REV INFECT DIS, V10, pS693
[3]  
BENOSMAN F, 1988, REV INFECT DIS, V10, pS703
[4]  
BERAN G W, 1972, Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health, V3, P433
[5]  
Beran G. W., 1971, Rabies,, P363
[6]  
BERAN GW, 1988, REV INFECT DIS, V10, pS672
[7]  
BOGEL K, 1990, B WORLD HEALTH ORGAN, V68, P281
[8]  
BOGEL K, 1986, B WORLD HEALTH ORGAN, V64, P883
[9]  
CHOMEL B, 1988, REV INFECT DIS, V10, pS697
[10]   POSTEXPOSURE PROPHYLAXIS FOR RABIES WITH ANTISERUM AND INTRADERMAL VACCINATION [J].
CHUTIVONGSE, S ;
WILDE, H ;
SUPICH, C ;
BAER, GM ;
FISHBEIN, DB .
LANCET, 1990, 335 (8694) :896-898