ATTRITION AND USE OF PROXY RESPONDENTS AND AUXILIARY INFORMATION IN THE SICILIAN NEUROEPIDEMIOLOGIC STUDY

被引:17
作者
GRIGOLETTO, F
ANDERSON, DW
ROCCA, WA
MENEGHINI, F
MORGANTE, L
REGGIO, A
SAVETTIERI, G
DIPERRI, R
机构
[1] NINCDS,BIOMETRY & FIELD STUDIES BRANCH,BETHESDA,MD
[2] SMID CTR,ITALIAN MULTICTR STUDY DEMENTIA,FLORENCE,ITALY
[3] FIDIA RES LABS,DEPT BIOSTAT & EPIDEMIOL,I-35031 ABANO TERME,ITALY
[4] UNIV MESSINA,DEPT NEUROL,MESSINA,ITALY
[5] UNIV CATANIA,DEPT NEUROL,CATANIA,ITALY
[6] UNIV PALERMO,DEPT NEUROL,PALERMO,ITALY
关键词
BIAS (EPIDEMIOLOGY); DATA COLLECTION; EPIDEMIOLOGIC METHODS; PREVALENCE; QUESTIONNAIRES;
D O I
10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a116983
中图分类号
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要
Two-phase prevalence surveys with screening (phase 1) and examination (phase 2) are useful for some chronic diseases. Attrition, which may bias estimates, occurs in either phase because some eligible subjects die before contact, some refuse to cooperate, some are incapacitated, and some are unreachable. This investigation relates to a survey of neurologic diseases conducted in three municipalities of Sicily (prevalence date, November 1, 1987) and considers the attrition experienced and the use of proxy respondents in phase 1 and auxiliary information in phase 2 to offset, in part, this attrition. Regarding case finding, the salvage effort was more productive for deceased and incapacitated subjects. The age, sex, and household size of the subject were related to phase 1 attrition, but only age was related for all four attrition groups-deceased, refusing, incapacitated, and unreachable subjects. On the basis of information from proxy respondents, the educational levels of refusing and unreachable subjects were compared with those of subjects screened directly. Refusing subjects were less educated, and unreachable subjects were more educated. The proxy respondent performance, as indicated by ''don't know'' responses, was better with screening items concerning facial paralysis and mouth drooping (and not limb sensory abnormalities or impaired consciousness), better with younger subjects, and worse with refusing or incapacitated subjects.
引用
收藏
页码:219 / 228
页数:10
相关论文
共 12 条
  • [1] PREVALENCE SURVEYS OF NEUROLOGIC DISORDERS - METHODOLOGIC IMPLICATIONS OF THE COPIAH COUNTY STUDY
    ANDERSON, DW
    SCHOENBERG, BS
    HAERER, AF
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1988, 41 (04) : 339 - 345
  • [2] Anderson DW, 1990, ITAL J APPL STAT, V2, P309
  • [3] ESSAY ON SCREENING, OR ON 2-PHASE SAMPLING, APPLIED TO SURVEYS OF A COMMUNITY
    DEMING, WE
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL STATISTICAL REVIEW, 1977, 45 (01) : 29 - 37
  • [4] Deming WE, 1969, NEW DEV SURVEY SAMPL, P652
  • [5] PSYCHOPATHOLOGY AND ATTRITION IN THE EPIDEMIOLOGIC CATCHMENT-AREA SURVEYS
    EATON, WW
    ANTHONY, JC
    TEPPER, S
    DRYMAN, A
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1992, 135 (09) : 1051 - 1059
  • [6] HENNEKENS CH, 1907, EPIDEMIOLOGY MED
  • [7] Hosmer DW, 1989, APPLIED LOGISTIC REG
  • [8] VALIDATING SCREENING INSTRUMENTS FOR NEUROEPIDEMIOLOGIC SURVEYS - EXPERIENCE IN SICILY
    MENEGHINI, F
    ROCCA, WA
    ANDERSON, DW
    GRIGOLETTO, F
    MORGANTE, L
    REGGIO, A
    SAVETTIERI, G
    DIPERRI, R
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1992, 45 (04) : 319 - 331
  • [9] DOOR-TO-DOOR PREVALENCE SURVEY OF NEUROLOGICAL DISEASES IN A SICILIAN POPULATION - BACKGROUND AND METHODS
    MENEGHINI, F
    ROCCA, WA
    GRIGOLETTO, F
    MORGANTE, L
    REGGIO, A
    SAVETTIERI, G
    DIPERRI, R
    ANDERSON, DW
    [J]. NEUROEPIDEMIOLOGY, 1991, 10 (02) : 70 - 85
  • [10] PROXY RESPONDENTS IN EPIDEMIOLOGIC RESEARCH
    NELSON, LM
    LONGSTRETH, WT
    KOEPSELL, TD
    VANBELLE, G
    [J]. EPIDEMIOLOGIC REVIEWS, 1990, 12 : 71 - 86