FAILURE OF ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY TO DIAGNOSE BRAIN DEATH IN COMATOSE CHILDREN

被引:66
作者
ASHWAL, S [1 ]
SCHNEIDER, S [1 ]
机构
[1] LOMA LINDA UNIV,SCH MED,DEPT NEUROL,LOMA LINDA,CA 92354
关键词
D O I
10.1002/ana.410060609
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Two isoelectric electroencephalograms obtained 24 hours apart support a clinical diagnosis of brain death in prolonged coma. Without documentation of electrocerebral silence, physicians are reluctant to discontinue vital support systems. A radionuclide bolus technique has been developed that documents the absence of cerebral blood flow in suspected brain death and supplements the flat EEG. In a recent review of this technique, all 27 adults who had EEG activity maintained the integrity of their cerebral blood flow. This contrasts to our studies of 5 children, all of whom demonstrated persistent EEG activity but had no evidence of cerebral blood flow by either the isotope bolus technique (5 patients) or cerebral angiography (4 patients). These children (mean age, 7 months) lacked cephalic reflexes and were maintained on assisted ventilation for an average of 15 days. Multiple electroencephalographic tracings persistently demonstrated low‐voltage cortical activity over this time. Despite the lack of cerebral blood flow, all patients were continued on respiratory support. At autopsy, extensive brain liquefaction necrosis was noted. In comatose children, EEG monitoring may be of limited value while cerebral blood flow measurements can provide more practical and prognostic information. Copyright © 1979 American Neurological Association
引用
收藏
页码:512 / 517
页数:6
相关论文
共 13 条
[1]   RADIONUCLIDE BOLUS ANGIOGRAPHY - TECHNIQUE FOR VERIFICATION OF BRAIN DEATH IN INFANTS AND CHILDREN [J].
ASHWAL, S ;
SMITH, AJK ;
TORRES, F ;
LOKEN, M ;
CHOU, SN .
JOURNAL OF PEDIATRICS, 1977, 91 (05) :722-728
[2]  
BARLOW JS, 1976, GUIDELINES EEG AM EL, P21
[3]  
BICKFORD RG, 1973, COMPUTERIZED TECHNIQ
[4]  
BUSHART W, 1969, MED KLIN, V64, P84
[5]  
GOODMAN J M, 1977, Journal of the American Medical Association, V238, P966, DOI 10.1001/jama.238.9.966
[6]   DIAGNOSTIC ELECTRO-SOUS-CORTICO-GRAPHIQUE DE LA MORT DU SYSTEME NERVEUX CENTRAL AU COURS DE CERTAINS COMAS [J].
JOUVET, M .
ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY AND CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY, 1959, 11 (04) :805-808
[7]   BRAIN DEATH .1. ANGIOGRAPHIC CORRELATION WITH RADIOISOTOPIC BOLUS TECHNIQUE FOR EVALUATION OF CRITICAL DEFICIT OF CEREBRAL BLOOD-FLOW [J].
KOREIN, J ;
BRAUNSTEIN, P ;
GEORGE, A ;
WICHTER, M ;
KRICHEFF, I ;
LIEBERMAN, A ;
PEARSON, J .
ANNALS OF NEUROLOGY, 1977, 2 (03) :195-205
[8]   CEREBRAL DEATH AND ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM [J].
SILVERMAN, D ;
SAUNDERS, MG ;
SCHWAB, RS ;
MASLAND, RL .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1969, 209 (10) :1505-+
[9]  
TROGABORG WN, 1973, ELECTROENCEPHALOGR C, V35, P301
[10]   NEUROPATHOLOGICAL FINDINGS IN IRREVERSIBLE COMA - CRITIQUE OF RESPIRATOR BRAIN [J].
WALKER, AE ;
DIAMOND, EL ;
MOSELEY, J .
JOURNAL OF NEUROPATHOLOGY AND EXPERIMENTAL NEUROLOGY, 1975, 34 (04) :295-323