BEHAVIOR SIMULTANEOUSLY MAINTAINED BY BOTH PRESENTATION AND TERMINATION OF NOXIOUS STIMULI

Lever pressing by two squirrel monkeys was maintained under a 3‐minute variable‐interval schedule of response‐produced electric‐shock presentation. At the same time, responding on a second lever was maintained under a 3‐minute fixed‐interval schedule of termination of the shock‐presentation schedule and shock‐correlated stimuli. Under the termination schedule, the first response after a 3‐minute period produced a 1‐minute timeout, during which no events occurred and responding had no scheduled consequence. Relatively high and constant rates of responding were maintained on the lever where responding produced shock. Lower rates and positively accelerated patterns of responding occurred on the lever where responding terminated the shock schedule. Thus, responding was simultaneously maintained by presentation of an event and by termination of a stimulus associated with that event. Rates and patterns of responding on each lever were reversed when the schedules arranged on each lever were reversed on two occasions. When shock intensity was increased from 0 to 10 mA, responding maintained both by presentation of shock and by termination of the shock schedule increased, but responding maintained by shock presentation increased to a greater extent. Positive and negative reinforcement, usually regarded as separate behavioral processes involving different events, can coexist when behavior is controlled by different contingencies involving the same event. 1978 Society for the Experimental Analysis of Behavior