GETTING CONTEXTUAL AND NONLOCAL ELEMENTS-OF-REALITY THE EASY WAY

被引:48
作者
CLIFTON, R
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1119/1.17239
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
What if Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen were right that quantum mechanics is incomplete, and there do exist ''elements-of-reality'' corresponding to all observables whether or not they are compatible? The implications are surprising. Not only must the values of these elements-of-reality depend upon what measurements are actually performed on the system, but also upon measurements performed at spacelike separation from it! The former dependence has been dubbed ''contextualism,'' and the latter ''nonlocality.'' It is important for students to understand the necessity of these two features, if only to reinforce the point that a straightforward classical recasting of quantum theory in terms of pre-existing measurement independent elements-of-reality is not feasible. Unfortunately the argument for contextualism, in particular, is daunting due to its reliance on an elaborate geometrical argument. I aim here to minimize the geometry needed to argue for contextualism by using some ideas inspired by the original arguments of Bell and of Kochen and Specker. Using similar methods, I simplify the closely related geometrical argument for nonlocality due to Heywood and Redhead and to Stairs.
引用
收藏
页码:443 / 447
页数:5
相关论文
共 31 条
[21]  
MERMIN, 1992, PHYS REV LETT, V68, P2981
[22]   SIMPLE UNIFIED FORM FOR THE MAJOR NO-HIDDEN-VARIABLES THEOREMS [J].
MERMIN, ND .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 1990, 65 (27) :3373-3376
[23]   BRINGING HOME THE ATOMIC WORLD - QUANTUM MYSTERIES FOR ANYBODY [J].
MERMIN, ND .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 1981, 49 (10) :940-943
[24]   QUANTUM MYSTERIES REVISITED [J].
MERMIN, ND .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 1990, 58 (08) :731-734
[25]  
PENROSE R, 1992, IN PRESS P CES C
[26]  
Peres A., 1988, MICROPHYSICAL REALIT, V2, P115
[27]   SUBSTITUTION AND TRUTH IN QUANTUM LOGIC [J].
PITOWSKY, I .
PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 1982, 49 (03) :380-401
[28]  
Redhead M., 1989, INCOMPLETENESS NONLO
[29]   QUANTUM LOGIC, REALISM, AND VALUE DEFINITENESS [J].
STAIRS, A .
PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 1983, 50 (04) :578-602
[30]   BELLS THEOREM AND THE FOUNDATIONS OF QUANTUM PHYSICS [J].
STAPP, HP .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 1985, 53 (04) :306-317