IRRELEVANT TONES PRODUCE AN IRRELEVANT SPEECH EFFECT - IMPLICATIONS FOR PHONOLOGICAL CODING IN WORKING MEMORY

A series of studies addresses the possibility that tones disrupt serial recall of visually presented material in the same way as speech. A stream of changing tones is as disruptive of visual serial recall as 4 syllables (Experiments 1 and 2). Similar effects were also shown with a repeated syllable that changed only in pitch (Experiment 3). Just as for speech, the effect of tones is not at encoding but during storage of the serial lists (Experiments 4 and 5). The results suggest that speech and tones are equipotent in their capacity to disrupt short-term memory. A ''blackboard'' model of working memory to account for the effects is outlined.