DIAGNOSTIC-ACCURACY AND CLINICAL UTILITY OF THERMOGRAPHY FOR LUMBAR RADICULOPATHY - A METAANALYSIS

被引:33
作者
HOFFMAN, RM
KENT, DL
DEYO, RA
机构
[1] Medical Service, Health Services Research, Seattle Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Seattle, WA
[2] Departments of Medicine and Health Services, University of Washington, Seattle, WA
关键词
THERMOGRAPHY; LUMBAR RADICULOPATHY; SCIATICA; TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT; METAANALYSIS;
D O I
10.1097/00007632-199106000-00005
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
The role of thermography for diagnosing lumbar radiculopathy was evaluated by literature review and metanalysis. From 81 relevant citations, 28 studies could be analyzed for diagnostic-accuracy data (sensitivity and specificity) and method. Diagnostic-accuracy data varied significantly between studies; therefore meaningful pooled summary statistics could not be reported. Twenty-seven studies had major methodologic flaws including biased test interpretations, faulty cohort assembly, poor clinical descriptions, and small sample size. The only study of reasonably high quality found no discriminant value for liquid-crystal thermography. The role of thermography remains unclear. Rigorous clinical research is required to establish its diagnostic accuracy and clinical utility. Thermography cannot be recommended currently for routine clinical use in evaluating low-back pain.
引用
收藏
页码:623 / 628
页数:6
相关论文
共 118 条
[31]  
Frymoyer J.W., Back pain and sciatica, N Engl J Med, 318, pp. 291-300, (1988)
[32]  
Frymoyer J.W., Haugh L.D., Thermography: A call for scientific studies to establish its diagnostic efficacy, Orthopedics, 9, pp. 699-700, (1986)
[33]  
Genovese E.M., Sieber G.F., Correlation of Thermography with Other Tests in 100 Patients with Radiculopathy.8
[34]  
Getty C., Bony Sciatica: The value of thermography, electromyography, and water-soluble myelography, Clin Sports Med, 5, pp. 327-342, (1986)
[35]  
Gillstrom P., Thermography in low back pain and sciatica, Arch Orthop Trauma Surg, 104, pp. 31-36, (1985)
[36]  
Goldberg G.S., Correlation of the Lumbar Thermogram with Other Procedures in 60 Patients.8, pp. 185-189
[37]  
Goldberg G.S., Infrared imaging and magnetic resonance imaging correlated in 35 cases, Thermology, 1, pp. 207-211, (1986)
[38]  
Goldberg G.S., Thermography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging Correlated in 31 Cases.6, pp. 54-58
[39]  
Goldberg H.I., Heinz E.R., Taveras J.M., Thermography in neurological patients, Acta Radiol, 5, pp. 786-795, (1966)
[40]  
Goldie I., Is thermography more than an adjuvant in orthopedic diagnostics?, Orthopedics, 8, pp. 1128-1129, (1985)