基于因果推理的政策评估:一个实验与准实验设计的统一框架

被引:16
作者
李文钊
徐文
机构
[1] 中国人民大学公共管理学院
关键词
因果推理; 潜在结果模型; 政策评估; 随机实验设计; 准实验设计;
D O I
10.19744/j.cnki.11-1235/f.2022.0179
中图分类号
D035 [国家行政管理];
学科分类号
1204 ; 120401 ;
摘要
因果推理的可信革命正在对计量经济学、统计学、生物学等学科产生深远的影响,回归实验主义传统成为殊途同归之路。政策评估既是检验因果推理的重要场景,又可以通过引入因果推理提升其科学性。本研究试图发展基于因果推理的政策评估科学,重点讨论因果推理的理论基础,即潜在结果模型、内部效度和外部效度理论、选择性偏差模型以及因果图等4种理论,并阐明不同因果推理理论的内在逻辑和一致性。同时,本文还将基于潜在结果模型,提出一个实验和准实验设计的统一框架,并结合政策评估案例进行阐述,他们为政策评估的科学性奠定了基础。对于随机实验设计,重点讨论实验室实验、调查实验和实地实验。对于准实验设计,重点讨论匹配法、双重差分、合成控制、工具变量和断点回归。
引用
收藏
页码:104 / 123
页数:20
相关论文
共 93 条
[11]  
因果推理中的科学模型——反事实、选择性偏差与赫克曼结构计量经济学模型[A]. 李文钊.实证社会科学(第六卷)[C]. 2018
[12]  
因果推断实用计量方法[M]. 上海财经大学出版社 , 邱嘉平, 2020
[13]  
组织与管理研究的实证方法[M]. 北京大学出版社 , 陈晓萍, 2018
[14]  
Does the frequency of reminders matter for their effectiveness? A randomized controlled trial[J] . Antinyan Armenak,Asatryan Zareh,Dai Zhixin,Wang Kezhi.Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization . 2021
[15]   Reducing Compliance Demands in Government Benefit Programs Improves the Psychological Well-Being of Target Group Members [J].
Baekgaard, Martin ;
Mikkelsen, Kim Sass ;
Madsen, Jonas Krogh ;
Christensen, Julian .
JOURNAL OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION RESEARCH AND THEORY, 2021, 31 (04) :806-821
[16]  
The Challenges of Universal Health Insurance in Developing Countries: Experimental Evidence from Indonesia’s National Health Insurance<sup>?</sup>[J] . Banerjee Abhijit,Finkelstein Amy,Hanna Rema,Olken Benjamin A.,Ornaghi Arianna,Sumarto Sudarno.American Economic Review . 2021 (9)
[17]  
Performance Management Meets Red Tape: Bounded Rationality, Negativity Bias, and Resource Dependence[J] . Sounman Hong.Public Administration Review . 2020 (6)
[18]  
Can Reminders and Incentives Improve Implementation Within Government? Evidence from a Field Experiment[J] . Simon Calmar Andersen,Ulrik Hvidman.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory . 2020
[19]  
The impact of China’s ‘Atmosphere Ten Articles’ policy on total factor productivity of energy exploitation: Empirical evidence using synthetic control methods[J] . Jiachao Peng,Jianzhong Xiao,Lian Zhang,Teng Wang.Resources Policy . 2020 (C)
[20]   The Influence of High Schools on Developing Public Service Motivation [J].
Holt, Stephen B. .
INTERNATIONAL PUBLIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2019, 22 (01) :127-175