Replace the NOAEL and LOAEL with the BMDL01 and BMDL10

被引:19
作者
Kodell, Ralph L. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Arkansas Med Sci, Dept Biostat, Little Rock, AR 72205 USA
关键词
Benchmark dose; Background risk; Continuous endpoints; Point of departure; DOSE-RESPONSE ASSESSMENT; ADVERSE EFFECT LEVELS; RISK-ASSESSMENT; DEVELOPMENTAL TOXICITY; FETAL WEIGHT; MODEL; INHALATION; ISSUES;
D O I
10.1007/s10651-007-0075-3
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Although benchmark-dose methodology has existed for more than 20 years, benchmark doses (BMDs) still have not fully supplanted the no-observed-adverse-effect level (NOAEL) and lowest-observed-adverse-effect level (LOAEL) as points of departure from the experimental dose-response range for setting acceptable exposure levels of toxic substances. Among the issues involved in replacing the NOAEL (LOAEL) with a BMD are (1) which added risk level(s) above background risk should be targeted as benchmark responses (BMRs), (2) whether to apply the BMD methodology to both carcinogenic and noncarcinogenic toxic effects, and (3) how to model continuous health effects that aren't observed in a natural risk-based context like dichotomous health effects. This paper addresses these issues and recommends specific BMDs to replace the NOAEL and LOAEL.
引用
收藏
页码:3 / 12
页数:10
相关论文
共 35 条
[1]   Confidence bands for low-dose risk estimation with quantal response data [J].
Al-Saidy, OM ;
Piegorsch, WW ;
West, RW ;
Nitcheva, DK .
BIOMETRICS, 2003, 59 (04) :1056-1062
[2]   DOSE-RESPONSE ASSESSMENT FOR DEVELOPMENTAL TOXICITY .3. STATISTICAL-MODELS [J].
ALLEN, BC ;
KAVLOCK, RJ ;
KIMMEL, CA ;
FAUSTMAN, EM .
FUNDAMENTAL AND APPLIED TOXICOLOGY, 1994, 23 (04) :496-509
[3]   DOSE-RESPONSE ASSESSMENT FOR DEVELOPMENTAL TOXICITY .2. COMPARISON OF GENERIC BENCHMARK DOSE ESTIMATES WITH NO OBSERVED ADVERSE EFFECT LEVELS [J].
ALLEN, BC ;
KAVLOCK, RJ ;
KIMMEL, CA ;
FAUSTMAN, EM .
FUNDAMENTAL AND APPLIED TOXICOLOGY, 1994, 23 (04) :487-495
[4]  
[Anonymous], COMP ENV RISK ASS
[5]   Model uncertainty and risk estimation for experimental studies of quantal responses [J].
Bailer, AJ ;
Noble, RB ;
Wheeler, MW .
RISK ANALYSIS, 2005, 25 (02) :291-299
[6]   BENCHMARK DOSE WORKSHOP - CRITERIA FOR USE OF A BENCHMARK DOSE TO ESTIMATE A REFERENCE DOSE [J].
BARNES, DG ;
DASTON, GP ;
EVANS, JS ;
JARABEK, AM ;
KAVLOCK, RJ ;
KIMMEL, CA ;
PARK, C ;
SPITZER, HL .
REGULATORY TOXICOLOGY AND PHARMACOLOGY, 1995, 21 (02) :296-306
[7]   STATISTICAL-MODEL FOR FETAL DEATH, FETAL WEIGHT, AND MALFORMATION IN DEVELOPMENTAL TOXICITY STUDIES [J].
CATALANO, PJ ;
SCHARFSTEIN, DO ;
RYAN, LM ;
KIMMEL, CA ;
KIMMEL, GL .
TERATOLOGY, 1993, 47 (04) :281-290
[8]   CALCULATION OF BENCHMARK DOSES FROM CONTINUOUS DATA [J].
CRUMP, KS .
RISK ANALYSIS, 1995, 15 (01) :79-89
[9]   A NEW METHOD FOR DETERMINING ALLOWABLE DAILY INTAKES [J].
CRUMP, KS .
FUNDAMENTAL AND APPLIED TOXICOLOGY, 1984, 4 (05) :854-871
[10]   DOSE-RESPONSE ASSESSMENT FOR DEVELOPMENTAL TOXICITY .1. CHARACTERIZATION OF DATABASE AND DETERMINATION OF NO OBSERVED ADVERSE EFFECT LEVELS [J].
FAUSTMAN, EM ;
ALLEN, BC ;
KAVLOCK, RJ ;
KIMMEL, CA .
FUNDAMENTAL AND APPLIED TOXICOLOGY, 1994, 23 (04) :478-486