Self-Reported Limitations and Future Directions in Scholarly Reports: Analysis and Recommendations

被引:115
作者
Brutus, Stephane [1 ]
Aguinis, Herman [2 ]
Wassmer, Ulrich
机构
[1] Concordia Univ, John Molson Sch Business, Montreal, PQ H3G 1M8, Canada
[2] Indiana Univ, Bloomington, IN 47405 USA
关键词
research communication; methodology; limitations; validity; RESEARCH METHODOLOGY; MANAGEMENT RESEARCH; ORGANIZATIONAL SCIENCE; STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT; RESEARCH ARTICLES; DECISION-MAKING; METHOD VARIANCE; IMPACT; PERFORMANCE; TRENDS;
D O I
10.1177/0149206312455245
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
The authors content analyzed self-reported limitations and directions for future research in 1,276 articles published between 1982 and 2007 in the Academy of Management Journal, Administrative Science Quarterly, the Journal of Applied Psychology, the Journal of Management, and the Strategic Management Journal. In order of frequency, the majority of self-reported limitations, as well as directions for future research, pertains to threats to internal, external, and construct validity issues, and there is a significant increase in the reporting of these elements over time. Longitudinal analyses revealed that some of these increases varied across management subfields (i.e., business policy and strategy, organizational behavior, organizational theory, and human resource management), indicating unique research contexts within some research domains. Based on the analyses of self-reported limitations and future research directions, the authors offer eight guidelines for authors, reviewers, and editors. These guidelines refer to the need for authors to report limitations and to use a separate section for them and the need for reviewers to list limitations in their evaluations of manuscripts; authors and reviewers should prioritize limitations, and authors should report them in a way that describes their consequences for the interpretation of results. The guidelines for directions for future research focus on positioning them as a starting point for future research endeavors and for the advancement of theoretical issues. The authors also offer recommendations on how to use limitations and future research directions for the training of researchers. It is hoped that the adoption of these proposed guidelines and recommendations will maximize their value so that they can serve as true catalysts for further scientific progress in the field of management.
引用
收藏
页码:48 / 75
页数:28
相关论文
共 86 条
[1]   What We Know and Don't Know About Corporate Social Responsibility: A Review and Research Agenda [J].
Aguinis, Herman ;
Glavas, Ante .
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT, 2012, 38 (04) :932-968
[2]   Conducting field experiments using eLancing's natural environment [J].
Aguinis, Herman ;
Lawal, Sola O. .
JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING, 2012, 27 (04) :493-505
[3]   Walking New Avenues in Management Research Methods and Theories: Bridging Micro and Macro Domains [J].
Aguinis, Herman ;
Boyd, Brian K. ;
Pierce, Charles A. ;
Short, Jeremy C. .
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT, 2011, 37 (02) :395-403
[4]   Meta-Analytic Choices and Judgment Calls: Implications for Theory Building and Testing, Obtained Effect Sizes, and Scholarly Impact [J].
Aguinis, Herman ;
Dalton, Dan R. ;
Bosco, Frank A. ;
Pierce, Charles A. ;
Dalton, Catherine M. .
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT, 2011, 37 (01) :5-38
[5]   First Decade of Organizational Research Methods Trends in Design, Measurement, and Data-Analysis Topics [J].
Aguinis, Herman ;
Pierce, Charles A. ;
Bosco, Frank A. ;
Muslin, Ivan S. .
ORGANIZATIONAL RESEARCH METHODS, 2009, 12 (01) :69-112
[6]   ISSUES IN RESEARCH METHODOLOGY [J].
ALDAG, RJ ;
STEARNS, TM .
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT, 1988, 14 (02) :253-276
[7]  
American Psychological Association, 2009, Publication manual of the american Psychological Association, V6th
[8]   Research in the psychological laboratory: Truth or triviality? [J].
Anderson, CA ;
Lindsay, AJ ;
Bushman, BJ .
CURRENT DIRECTIONS IN PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 1999, 8 (01) :3-9
[9]  
[Anonymous], 1974, The sociology of science: Theoretical and empirical investigations
[10]  
[Anonymous], RES METHODS STRATEGY