Differential effects of heart rate reduction and β-blockade on left ventricular relaxation during exercise

Left ventricular (LV) relaxation is crucial for LV function, especially during exercise. We compared the effects of increasing doses of ivabradine, a selective inward hyperpolarization-activated current inhibitor, and atenolol on the rate and extent of LV relaxation (best fit method: time constant tau(BF), pressure asymptote P-BF) at rest and during exercise. Eight dogs were chronically instrumented to measure LV pressure and LV wall stresses. During exercise under saline, heart rate increased from 108 +/- 5 to 220 +/- 6 beats/min and tau(BF) was significantly reduced from 22 +/- 1 to 14 +/- 2 ms. At rest, atenolol but not ivabradine increased tau(BF). For similar heart rate reductions during exercise, atenolol impeded the shortening of tau(BF) (23 +/- 2 ms) whereas ivabradine had no effect (15 +/- 2 ms). The extent of the relaxation process (P-BF) at peak exercise was increased by ivabradine, and to a greater extent by atenolol, compared with saline. Thus, for a similar reduction in heart rate at rest and during exercise, ivabradine, in contrast with atenolol, does not exert any negative lusitropic effect.